• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Social Media Examiner

Your Guide to the Marketing Jungle

  • 🔥 Free Newsletter
  • 🎙️ Podcasts
    • Social Media Marketing Podcast
    • AI Explored Podcast
    • Social Media Marketing Talk Show
    • Our YouTube Channel
  • 🌟 AI Society
  • 🗓️ Marketing Conference
  • đź‘‹ About Us
    • Marketing Events
  • Search
  • Embrace AI & MarketingGet Ongoing Training & SupportBEGIN YOUR JOURNEY NOW

    4 Creative Ways to Generate Organic Instagram Engagement

    by George Mathew / November 26, 2019

    Want more engagement on your Instagram posts? Wondering how to entice people to engage with you on Instagram?

    In this article, you'll discover four out-of-the-ordinary ways to create Instagram posts that prompt people to engage with and click on your content.

    4 Creative Ways to Generate Organic Instagram Engagement by George Mathew on Social Media Examiner.

    #1: Encourage Instagram Engagement With Brand-Relevant Puzzles

    The typical image or video post on Instagram can generate, at best, a few seconds of engagement. Why not give your followers a mind-bender to keep them occupied and engaged with your post? Research shows that participating in activities results in better recall than simply talking about them. Additionally, puzzles engage people longer.

    Quizzes and puzzles make people stop in their tracks and think for a minute. If you also succeed in tapping into your audience's emotions, people will be more inclined to share the puzzles with their own networks. This generates engagement and provides interesting feedback for you.

    Keep in mind that the puzzle posts you create for Instagram should tie in with your overall brand message. Be sure to choose a theme that reflects your brand and its core message. Also, research topics that your followers will have an emotional connection with.

    Rebus Puzzles

    Mattress brand Casper's core value proposition is centered around relaxation and good sleep. With this in mind, the brand effectively ties engaging Instagram posts with their branding by delivering rest-related rebus puzzles via the feed and Stories. In fact, puzzles account for almost half of their posts with the highest number of comments.

    While Casper doesn't offer prizes for getting the right answers—just the thrill of having solved a puzzle—the posts create a ton of engagement. To illustrate, the post below got 3,800+ likes and 94 comments.

    ALT

    In addition to still graphics, Casper also posts animated rebus puzzles to both their Instagram feed and Stories and in ads. This animated rebus pulled in 19,800+ views.

    ALT

    Brain Teasers

    Curiosity is a publication that shares explanations of interesting facts and trivia. On Instagram, they use brain teasers to drive post engagement, platform views, and off-platform traffic, providing the explanations or solutions in content on their website. To get to those answers, viewers must view Curiosity's Instagram bio to find the link to the relevant article.

    This puzzle post received 6,200+ likes and more than 300 comments.

    ALT

    AI Business Society

    Ready to Unlock AI Marketing Breakthroughs?

    If you’re like most of us, you are trying to figure out how to use AI in your marketing. Here's the solution: The AI Business Society—a new AI marketing community from your friends at Social Media Examiner.

    The AI Business Society is the place to discover how to apply AI in your work. When you join, you'll boost your productivity, unlock your creativity, and make connections with other marketers on a similar journey.

    I'M READY TO BECOME AN AI-POWERED MARKETER

    #2: Grow Your Instagram Following With an Emoji Scavenger Hunt

    Another creative way to engage your audience on Instagram is with a mind-bender where your audience has to find hidden emojis. Chanel and Stevo of How Far From Home started hiding emojis in their travel photos as part of a fun weekly game on their popular Instagram account.

    Content like this has helped them attract over 167,000 followers on Instagram. They're indeed an enviable couple, quitting successful careers in advertising to travel the world. That's the reason for part of the excitement surrounding them. The other part is the clever ways they hide emojis inside their travel photos.

    ALT

    #3: Nurture a Community With a Recurring Instagram Challenge

    Generally, an Instagram challenge is when you choose a theme and ask your Instagram followers to share photos based on ideas that stem from that theme. The challenge may require participants to post photos daily, weekly, or monthly and the announcement is made in advance.

    Sometimes there are prizes, and other times there's only the satisfaction of having participated. The challenge is always to think ahead and creatively.

    What are the benefits of a recurring challenge on Instagram? It's a way to invite passive followers to actively create content you can use to fuel your own profile. You not only get content you can post on your account but also engage your audience at the same time.

    Designer and illustrator Joanne Hawker first launched her #MarchMeetTheMaker challenge in 2016. As the name suggests, this Instagram challenge takes place throughout the month of March.

    Here's how it works. Joanne, the creator of the challenge, selects a theme for each day of March and then designers create something about their business based on that theme. The idea is to tell their business's story in the context of an overarching theme. The challenge gives designers a platform to exhibit their work and grab free traffic.

    ALT

    Discover Proven Marketing Strategies and Tips

    Want to go even deeper with your marketing? Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast! Publishing weekly since 2012, the Social Media Marketing Podcast helps you navigate the constantly changing marketing jungle, with expert interviews from marketing pros.

    But don’t let the name fool you. This show is about a lot more than just social media marketing. With over 600 episodes and millions of downloads each year, this show has been a trusted source for marketers for well over a decade.

    CHECK OUT THE SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING PODCAST NOW

    Created by artist @jakeparker in 2009, the Inktober challenge helps artists create a habit of drawing daily, and thousands of artists participate annually. The best submissions get featured on the Inktober profile with one new drawing selected every day to reach a total of 31 drawings for all the days of October.

    Featured participants get a ton of exposure. To visualize this, book illustrator @tonigalmesdibuixos had some of his images featured in a post that received 63,400+ likes.

    ALT

    Here are broad outlines to create Instagram challenges that are as interesting as the ones highlighted above.

    Plan Your Posts for the Challenge

    Planning a month-long Instagram challenge is hard work. Ask friends and even active members of your community to come up with ideas that might be worthy of a challenge. When choosing a topic, pick something that fits with the overall mood of your brand.

    ALT

    Pro Tip: Set reminders for posting the challenge on time. Often, I simply take a photo of the challenge and set it up as the wallpaper on my phone. Because I check my phone umpteen times a day, it serves as my reminder.

    Choose a Hashtag for the Challenge

    The challenge hashtag is key. Be creative and think of something unique and closely tied to your brand. Ask participants to use the hashtag in their Instagram captions so you're able to track every image that's posted as part of the challenge. All you need to do to find the posts is search for the hashtag in the search bar.

    ALT

    Engage With Challenge Participants

    Engaging with people goes a long way toward improving participation rates in your challenge. Take your time to engage with them by commenting or liking their content. Many participants will reciprocate the behavior with other participants, creating a chain reaction. This helps build a sense of community, too.

    Promote Your Challenge on Other Platforms

    Spread the word about your Instagram challenge with the larger community outside of the platform. Promote it on your other social networks and even run paid ads to get it going.

    When Joanne and Jake started their respective challenges, they didn't have a lot of participants initially. But after repeating the challenge over the course of a few years, the number of participants grew exponentially.

    #4: Generate Link Clicks With Instructional Videos in Instagram Stories

    According to research by WR Hambrecht + Co, 7 days after a training session, participants forget 65% of the material covered. In 6 months, they forget almost everything they learned; the recall percentage is about 10%.

    However, an instructional video can give users a new level of experience that's simply absent in other media. Visually stimulating and multifaceted, video engages viewers in ways that text can rarely achieve and helps people remember concepts and details.

    Smitten Kitchen posts instructional cooking videos in their Instagram stories, like this one for chicken curry. As an added bonus, they use the See More link to drive traffic to the full recipe on their website.

    ALT

    Pro Tip: Consider doing your instructional videos live on Stories. There's a certain level of vulnerability in live-streaming that's impossible to replicate in recorded video. If you make mistakes, you own up and move ahead. You're not allowed to dwell on the past. This makes live video inherently challenging and deeply exciting for both the viewer and the participant.

    ALT

    Conclusion

    Instagram stories, videos, and contests all have great potential to tap into your audience's emotions and generate engagement. But instead of the usual posts that businesses tend to share, this article focuses on four out-of-the-ordinary types of content that will pique your audience's interest and encourage interactions.

    Puzzles that tie in with your overall brand message, emoji scavenger hunts, challenges around a relevant theme, and instructional videos are all ways to prompt your Instagram community to engage with your content.

    What do you think? Which of these types of content will you try on your Instagram account? Do you have any other creative content suggestions to add to this list? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

    More articles on Instagram marketing:

    • Discover six easy-to-use design tools that will make your Instagram stories more interesting.
    • Learn how to develop a customer-centered user-generated Instagram content strategy.
    • Find five ways to humanize your Instagram business account.
    AI EXPLORED

    Curious About How to Use AI?

    Our newest show, AI Explored, might be just what you're looking for. It's for marketers, creators, and entrepreneurs who want to understand how to use AI in their business.

    It's hosted by Michael Stelzner and explores this exciting new frontier in easy-to-understand terms.

    Pull up your favorite podcast app and search for AI Explored. Or click the button below for more information.

    I WANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT AI

    Tags: Instagram

    About the authorGeorge Mathew

    George Mathews has been writing about online marketing and CRO for 8+ years. Learn more about working with George at SeekDefo.
    Other posts by George Mathew »

    Get Social Media Examiner’s Future Articles in Your Inbox!

    Get our latest articles delivered to your email inbox and get the FREE Social Media Marketing Industry Report (43 pages, 50+ charts)!

    Industry Report Cover

    Worth Exploring:

    Facebook

    Marketing Help Explore More →

    Instagram

    Marketing Help Explore More →

    YouTube

    Marketing Help Explore More →

    Linkedin

    Marketing Help Explore More →

    AI

    Next Frontier Explore More →

    Social Media Marketing Industry Report

    Get Free Report →

    Social Marketing Trends

    The data you've been missing!

    Need a new plan? Discover how marketers plan to change their social activities in the 17th annual Social Media Marketing Industry Report. It reveals what marketers have planned for their social activities, content marketing, and more! Get this free report now and never miss another great article from us. Join more than 385,000 marketers!

    Simply click the button below to get the free report:

    Footer

    Your Guide to the Marketing Jungle
    Copyright © 2025 Social Media Examiner®
    All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy.

    Helpful Links

    • About us
    • Our content via email
    • Our podcasts
    • Our YouTube channel
    • Our live show
    • Our social media marketing industry report
    • Our generative AI marketing industry report
    • Sponsorship opportunities
    • RSS