Email Marketing Automation That Moves People to Action

Are you struggling to move beyond basic email broadcasts? Wondering how to turn your email marketing into a revenue-generating machine that works around the clock?

In this article, you'll discover how to leverage three levels of email automation to deliver the right message at the exact right moment for each recipient, creating a system that saves you time and drives consistent action from your audience.

Why Email Marketing Automation Is Effective Than Matters for Modern Marketers

Email offers something unique to marketers: an owned database of people who literally give you permission to put ideas in their inbox. 

What’s the difference between email marketing broadcasts and email marketing automation? 

Automated email sequences represent a fundamental shift from broadcasting on your schedule to delivering personalized messages when they mean the most to each recipient, triggered based on specific actions or inactions taken by that customer: 

• Someone signs up for your email list, and they get a welcome email immediately. 
• If someone abandons their cart, they receive a follow-up within hours. 
• Someone makes a purchase, and they enter an onboarding sequence. 

Jessica Best, founder of BetterAve and veteran email marketing strategist who has worked with major brands like Applebee's, Winnebago, and Planet Fitness, believes automated email is the key to systems that continue generating revenue until you turn them off. It delivers higher engagement and better conversion rates than other channels, and most importantly, attributable action that directly impacts your bottom line.

#1: Email Automation for a Newsletter Subscriber Welcome Sequence

The foundation of any email automation strategy starts with the welcome email sequence. 

A series of three emails delivers significantly better results than a single welcome email. This series should deliver over the first week to ten days, with strategic timing that maximizes engagement without overwhelming new subscribers.

Your First Welcome Email

A consumer will never be more engaged with your brand than the second after they signed up to receive your emails. This moment demands immediate response, which is why the first welcome email must be delivered immediately.

Your initial welcome email needs to accomplish three key objectives. 

First, you must establish your brand voice and tone to differentiate your brand and help new subscribers understand exactly who they'll be hearing from.

Second, every welcome email must include a clear next ask. Remember, this is email marketing. Don't simply thank people for subscribing and leave them hanging. Determine what would deepen their relationship with your brand. Do you want them to download additional content? Follow your social channels? Start shopping? The specific ask depends on your customer journey, but there must be an ask.

For B2B marketers, this might mean directing subscribers to additional free education or encouraging them to connect on social media. For e-commerce brands, the welcome email should often include products and even offers.

Third, you need to set appropriate delivery expectations. This expectation-setting should first be communicated on the signup form itself, not be buried in the welcome email.

Best shares the cautionary tale of a marketer who sent daily newsletters without ever telling subscribers they would receive daily emails. The result was a massive unsubscribe rate because subscribers felt overwhelmed by unexpected frequency.

Your Second Welcome Email

The second email typically arrives two to three days later. 

This message can take several directions based on your strategy. You might showcase social proof through customer reviews and testimonials, highlighting how satisfied customers describe their experience with your brand. Alternatively, you could present samples of your social media content, showing rather than simply telling subscribers about the value they'll find by following you on other platforms.

Your Third Welcome Email

The third email arrives on day eight, matching the same day of the week as the original subscription. If someone subscribed on Tuesday morning, perhaps Tuesday mornings represent their free time for consuming content.

This email often focuses on deepening the relationship through additional value, whether that's exclusive content, special offers, or community involvement opportunities.

Marketing Profs demonstrates this approach effectively by clearly labeling their welcome sequence. Each email indicates its position in the series with messages like “This is warm-up email one of three,” so subscribers know exactly what to expect.

Personalizing Email Automation for Newsletter Subscribers 

The most effective welcome sequences leverage whatever data you collect during the signup process to personalize the experience. This doesn't just mean inserting first names into subject lines. True personalization means matching the content of your emails to what the person actually wants based on their demonstrated interests.

If someone downloads a specific piece of content from your website, your welcome sequence should acknowledge that interest and provide related resources. If they came to your site through an article about Facebook marketing, your welcome emails might emphasize Facebook-related content and resources.

The key is using every available data point to create relevance. Where did they sign up? What page were they viewing? What product were they examining? All of this information can and should inform your automated response.

#2: Email Automation for Advanced Lead Nurturing

Lead nurturing automation addresses prospects who have demonstrated varying levels of purchase intent. 

Automation's critical advantage over human follow-up lies in speed. While sales teams should follow up on qualified leads, automation can beat even the fastest salesperson to the prospect's inbox.

This immediate response acknowledges the prospect's interest while they're still warm, sets expectations for the sales follow-up, and can help schedule subsequent phone calls by offering convenient times for contact.

This automation requires a more sophisticated approach that recognizes the difference between someone casually downloading a free resource and someone actively requesting a product demonstration.

The automated response must match the level of intent and commitment demonstrated by the prospect's actions.

For content downloads, the automation should mirror the welcome email approach but with more focus on education and nurturing. Best describes working with an HR client who tracks what topics prospects download and then sends a nurture stream focused specifically on that subject area. If someone downloads content about legal compliance, they receive additional resources about legal topics while the salesperson separately follows up through personal outreach.

For demo requests and other high-intent actions, the automation shifts toward sales support. These prospects have explicitly indicated readiness to engage with your sales process, so the automated emails should facilitate and accelerate that engagement rather than focusing on education.

Case Study: Winnebago’s Lead Nurture Email Automation

Winnebago offers downloadable brochures for each vehicle model available on their website, but they weren't leveraging these downloads for lead capture and nurturing.

The solution involved creating a comprehensive four-part email series triggered by brochure downloads. 

The first email delivered the requested brochure immediately while also sending it to the prospect's inbox for future reference. 

The second email provided deeper technical specifications for the specific model they'd examined. The third email featured behind-the-scenes and influencer videos showing detailed tours of the vehicle. The fourth email focused on reinforcing the Winnebago brand advantage over competitors.

This last element proved particularly crucial because Winnebago doesn't sell directly to consumers. They must sell through dealers who might have incentives to promote competing brands. The automation gave Winnebago direct access to prospects during their research phase, allowing them to build brand preference before prospects visited dealer showrooms.

The results spoke for themselves: a fifty-to-one return on investment. By matching back warranty registration email addresses to people who had been nurtured through the automation, Winnebago could directly attribute vehicle sales to their email nurturing efforts.

Personalizing Email Automation for Advanced Lead Nurturing

The most sophisticated lead nurturing automations use form data and behavioral signals to personalize not just the content but also the sender and approach. Geographic data can determine which local sales representative signs the emails. Product interest can dictate which specific content gets emphasized. Company size and industry can influence which case studies and testimonials get highlighted.

This personalization extends beyond the initial form submission. Click behavior within the emails provides additional signals about prospect interests and readiness. Someone who clicks on pricing information demonstrates a different intent than someone who only engages with educational content. These behavioral signals can trigger different follow-up sequences or alert sales teams to high-priority prospects.

The key principle remains matching the automation to the prospect's demonstrated intent and providing value at each step rather than immediately jumping to sales pitches.

#3: Email Automation for Post-Purchase Customer Automation Excellence

The moment after someone makes a purchase represents one of the most underutilized opportunities in email marketing. Sophisticated marketers recognize it as the beginning of a new phase in the customer relationship.

New customers are at their peak satisfaction and engagement immediately following a purchase. They've just validated their decision to choose your brand, and this psychological state creates unique opportunities for deeper engagement. However, this window doesn't last long, making immediate automated follow-up essential.

Post-purchase automation serves multiple strategic purposes: welcoming customers to your brand family, ensuring they have the best possible experience with their purchase, identifying and addressing any issues before they escalate, and creating opportunities for additional purchases or brand advocacy.

The most sophisticated post-purchase automations consider the entire customer lifecycle, not just the immediate post-purchase period. Best shares an insight from Winnebago's database: seventy percent of people who buy a Winnebago this year already own a Winnebago. This means their best prospects aren't new customers but existing customers ready to upgrade or replace their current vehicles.

This insight completely changes the post-purchase strategy. Rather than treating the sale as complete, it becomes the beginning of a long-term relationship designed to capture the next purchase. The automation focuses on maintaining engagement, providing ongoing value, and positioning the brand for the eventual replacement cycle.

Understanding these patterns in your own business reveals opportunities for long-term customer development rather than short-term transaction completion.

The Net Promoter Score Survey Follow-Up

One of the most effective post-purchase automations centers around the Net Promoter Score (NPS) survey. This single-question survey asks customers to rate their likelihood of recommending your business on a scale of one to ten. The elegance lies in its simplicity and the actionable insights it provides.

Best worked with a Mercedes-Benz dealership that took this approach to an extreme. Following their brand promise of “The best or nothing,” they only considered scores of ten out of ten as acceptable. Any score below ten triggered a personal phone call to address concerns—only customers who scored the experience as perfect received follow-up requests for reviews or referrals.

This systematic approach ensures that you're only asking satisfied customers to provide public reviews, protecting your online reputation while maximizing the likelihood of positive responses. It also provides early warning about dissatisfied customers, allowing you to address issues before they damage your brand through negative reviews or word of mouth.

Strategic Review and Referral Request Follow-Up

Rather than asking every customer for reviews, the best automations segment customers based on their satisfaction levels and only request reviews from those most likely to provide positive feedback.

The Mercedes-Benz example illustrates this perfectly. Customers who rated their experience as ten out of ten received a follow-up email saying, “Thank you. It is so wonderful to hear that you had such a great experience. Here is our Google review link.” This targeted approach results in higher response rates and better review quality than blanket requests to all customers.

The same principle applies to referral requests. Highly satisfied customers are significantly more likely to refer friends and colleagues, making satisfaction scores an effective screening mechanism for referral campaigns.

Cross-Selling and Upselling Follow-Up

Post-purchase automation also creates opportunities for additional sales, but these must be approached strategically to avoid damaging the customer relationship. The key lies in relevance and timing.

At Home, a retail client Best worked with, used sophisticated software called Certona (now part of Monetate) to analyze purchase behavior and recommend complementary products. Rather than suggesting additional items in the same category, the system identified products that typically accompany the customer's purchase.

Someone who bought a rug might receive suggestions for complementary home decor items, not additional rugs. Someone who purchased a specific furniture piece might see recommendations for accessories that enhance that piece. This approach feels helpful rather than pushy because the suggestions genuinely add value to the original purchase.

The same principle applies to abandoned cart scenarios. If someone looked at a rug but didn't purchase it, they might receive follow-up emails showcasing alternative rugs in different sizes, colors, or styles. The system recognized that they were interested in rugs but perhaps hadn't found the right match.

Other Notes From This Episode

• Connect with Michael Stelzner @Stelzner on Instagram and @Mike_Stelzner on X.
• Watch this interview and other exclusive content from Social Media Examiner on YouTube.

Where to subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube Music | YouTube | Amazon Music | RSS

✋🏽 If you enjoyed this episode of the Social Media Marketing podcast, please head over to Apple Podcasts, leave a rating, write a review, and subscribe.

---

Stay Up-to-Date: Get New Marketing Articles Delivered to You!

Don't miss out on upcoming social media marketing insights and strategies! Sign up to receive notifications when we publish new articles on Social Media Examiner. Our expertly crafted content will help you stay ahead of the curve and drive results for your business. Click the link below to sign up now and receive our annual report!