Instagram Content Strategy: Attracting Quality Leads and Sales

Are you struggling to turn Instagram followers into paying customers? Wondering how to optimize your content strategy to generate qualified leads organically?

Instagram isn't just for building brand awareness—it's a powerful platform for lead generation and sales. With over two billion users and a range of content formats like Reels, Stories, and Lives, the platform gives you tools to attract, nurture, and convert your ideal audience.

In this article, you'll learn how to implement a proven Instagram content strategy designed by expert Elizabeth Marberry. You'll discover how to optimize your profile, audit your content, map out a conversion journey, and use strategic posts and DM automation to attract leads and close sales—all without spending a dime on ads.

Why Instagram Matters for Lead Generation and Sales

Instagram is a powerful platform for generating leads and sales, not just for exposure. According to Elizabeth Marberry, Instagram marketing strategy expert, the platform hosts over two billion Instagram users across all demographics—not just Gen Z. This massive user base means your ideal clients or customers are likely spending time there.

Instagram's diverse content formats make it uniquely positioned to support businesses. The platform offers multiple surfaces, such as Reels, Instagram Stories, carousels, and Instagram Live, that allow brands to showcase their values and personality in different ways. These various Instagram posts enable you to bring your brand to life, nurture relationships with potential customers, and convert followers into leads.

When content is used correctly, Instagram becomes more than just a visibility tool; if you focus solely on follower growth, you're leaving money on the table. 

Take Marberry's own experience with her dance studio business, Wedding Dance Coach. After implementing a strategic Instagram approach, she grew her combined social following to over 120,000 followers in just twelve months. This visibility led to an 84% increase in revenue, over 5,000 hot prospects on her email list, and the successful launch of a virtual studio.

Her Instagram presence even attracted unexpected PR opportunities, including an interview request from “This Morning,” the biggest morning show in the UK—all through organic content without spending on paid ads.

Here's her proven organic Instagram strategy.

A Proven Instagram Content Strategy

According to Marberry, visitors decide within five seconds whether to follow you, making your profile crucial in converting casual browsers into followers and, eventually, customers.

The foundation of your Instagram lead generation strategy starts with optimizing your profile.

#1: Optimize Your Instagram Profile Header

Photo: Show People, Not Just Logos

Your profile photo occupies valuable real estate on Instagram. While established brands like Target or Social Media Examiner can use their recognizable logos, most businesses should consider using images that include people.

Marberry explains, “People buy people, not products or services. Social media is social—they don't want to come to your page and feel like they're looking at your magazine.”

For example, if you're a wedding florist, use a close-up headshot of a bride holding a bouquet instead of posting a photo of flowers. This image creates an immediate human connection. Marberry's dance studio uses an image of a couple dancing with their faces clearly visible.

For the best results, use a bright background that will stand out in the sea of profile photos when users scroll through Stories or their feed.

Username and Name Field: Leverage SEO Opportunities

Both your username and name fields are crawled by search on Instagram, meaning they affect how discoverable you are when people search for specific terms.

“This is not the time to get fancy,” Marberry advises. For example, if you're a wealth management coach, don't use creative terminology like “wealth portal opener” in your name field. Instead, use the actual search terms your ideal clients would type in, such as “wealth management coach” or “consultant.”

Your username can be your brand name, while your name field can include additional descriptive terms. Instagram has become more generous with character limits in the name field, allowing you to include keywords that help potential clients find you.

Bio: Leverage Three Strategic Lines

Your Instagram bio should be structured in three distinct parts:

Line 1: Who Your Account Is For and What Content You'll Create: The first line of your bio needs to clearly state who your target audience is and what kind of content they can expect from your page. Many businesses make the mistake of focusing their bio entirely on themselves and their accolades rather than communicating value to potential followers.

Marberry shares the example of her dance studio's first bio line: “Helping nervous non-dancers and madly in love couples rock their first dance with confidence.” This phrase immediately tells visitors what they'll gain by following the account.

Line 2: Credibility (Optional): The second line is optional but can help you establish your expertise or credibility. For example, one of Marberry's clients, who owns a seven-figure Etsy shop, includes social proof information in the second line of her bio. Other credibility indicators might include “As seen in Vogue” or similar accomplishments that position you as an authority.

Line 3: Clear Call to Action: The final line of your bio should direct visitors to take a specific next step. This is where you get strategic about moving followers from Instagram to a channel you own, like your email list. For example, Marberry's bio includes “Free monetize your IG guide” with an emoji pointing down to the link. Other CTAs might include “Listen to the podcast” or “Grab your ticket now.”

Pro Tip: Use emojis strategically to break up text and make your bio more scannable, but don't overdo it.

#2: Develop Highlight Albums: Create Clear Visual Categories

The highlight covers that appear beneath your bio give visitors a quick snapshot of what your business offers. While Marberry notes that most people won't actually open and click through your highlights, they contribute to the visual aesthetic of your profile and provide an at-a-glance overview of your business categories.

For your highlights:

• Update covers to incorporate your brand colors
• Label them clearly with as few words as possible
• Use them to showcase the main categories or “buckets” of your business

For example, Marberry's highlights include simple labels like “Coaching,” “Podcast,” “Speaking,” “About Me,” and “Free Guide,” giving visitors an immediate understanding of her business offerings.

#3: Pin 3 Strategic Posts: Your Top Priorities

Instagram allows you to pin up to three posts at the top of your profile grid. These pinned posts should strategically introduce visitors to your brand and guide them toward conversion. Marberry recommends the following structure:

First Pinned Post: Founder's Story or Brand Story: Use this post to tell visitors why you created your business, what you're passionate about, and the story behind your brand. This helps people connect emotionally with your company and builds investment in what your business does.

Second Pinned Post: Clear Call to Action: This post should lead people to either a freebie (lead magnet) or a paid offer. Create content that adds value while naturally guiding viewers toward your CTA. This could be in the form of a Reel or carousel post.

Third Pinned Post: Value-Adding Content: The final pinned post should be something fun that demonstrates your expertise, shows your personality, or provides a quick win for your audience. This gives potential followers a taste of the value they'll receive if they follow your account.

Marberry notes that while Reels tend to perform better, carousel posts can also be effective for pinned content. The goal is to give new visitors clear entry points to engage with your brand.

#4: Audit Your Existing Content Strategy

After optimizing your profile, the next step is to audit your existing content to identify areas for improvement. Marberry recommends examining your last nine posts or the last three months of content, depending on how active you've been.

Ask yourself these key questions:

1. Does your content deliver on the promise of your bio? Suppose your bio says you'll teach gluten-free baking in under ten minutes, but your feed is filled with personal photos and unrelated content. This disconnect will confuse and alienate potential followers.
2. Does your content align with your business goals? If your goal was to grow your email list, but none of your recent posts included a call to action for your lead magnet, you've missed opportunities for conversion.
3. Are you using clear, strategic calls to action? Your CTA doesn't always need to be promotional—it could be as simple as “Heart this if you can relate” or “Tag a business bestie who needs this message”—but it should guide followers toward the engagement or action you want.

For posts that don't align with your strategy, you have options:

• For Reels, you can hide them from your profile grid by clicking the three dots and selecting “Hide from profile grid”
• If photos and carousels don't align with your strategy, you might need to delete them and focus on producing more strategic content in the future.

Remember that consistency with your brand promise is key to building trust with your audience.

#5: Map Your Customer Journey

After auditing your content, you need to clarify the customer journey for your ideal client or customer on Instagram. Many businesses fall into a content creation “hamster wheel,” chasing follower growth without a clear plan for what happens after someone follows them.

“Start with the end in mind,” Marberry advises. If your goal is to sell 100 tickets to a conference by June 1st, work backward from that goal to determine your content strategy.

Here's how a typical customer journey works on Instagram:

1. A potential customer discovers your content (often a Reel) while scrolling through Instagram
2. They tap on your handle and visit your profile
3. Within seconds, they decide whether to follow you based on your optimized profile
4. They begin consuming your content, perhaps binging on your posts
5. Through strategic CTAs, you guide them to take an action (comment a keyword)
6. You use DM automation to send them a direct link to your offer or lead magnet
7. They move from Instagram into your owned marketing channels (email list, booking calendar, etc.)

Marberry shares a success story from one of her clients, a luxury jewelry store in Denver. The store optimized its profile, created targeted content to attract its ideal clients (Gen Z customers looking for engagement rings), and used a clear call to action: “Comment ‘connect' and we will DM you a link to our calendar.”

This strategy successfully converted an Instagram follower into a high-ticket sale. The potential customer discovered their content, commented on their Reel, received a calendar link via DM automation, booked an in-store appointment, and ultimately purchased an engagement ring—all from one piece of organic content.

This example is particularly powerful because before implementing this strategy, the jewelry store had been spending $2,000 per month on paid Instagram ads with zero conversions. Their strategic organic approach yielded better results without the ad spend.

#6: Develop Your Content Strategy

With your profile optimized and your customer journey mapped out, it's time to develop a content strategy that attracts and converts your ideal audience.

Your number one job as a marketer is to know your ideal client like the back of your hand.” Focus on understanding:

• Their pain points and struggles
• How they describe their problems (in their own words)
• What they desire, and why
• How your product or service solves their problems

This knowledge allows you to create content that speaks directly to your audience's needs and positions your business as the solution.

The Hook-Value-CTA Formula for Creating Effective Organic Instagram Content 

A simple formula for creating engaging content is:

1. Hook – Capture attention in the first few seconds
2. Value – Deliver useful information or insights
3. CTA – Tell viewers what to do next

The hook is crucial—viewers will keep scrolling if you don't capture attention immediately. Effective hooks often use text-on-screen that addresses a pain point or promises a solution. For example, one of Marberry's viral Reels for her dance studio used the hook “5 First Dance Music Fails,” which immediately grabbed the attention of couples planning weddings.

When creating content, focus on delivering value that aligns with what you promised in your bio. This will build trust and position you as an expert in your field.

Leverage Trial Reels for A/B Testing Your Content

Instagram's Trial Reels feature is a powerful tool for testing content effectiveness. This feature allows you to post Reels that are only shown to people who don't already follow you—a completely cold audience—without appearing on your profile.

These test reels allow you to A/B test different approaches and see which resonates most with potential followers. For example, Marberry shares how one client tested the same nature video with three different opening lines:

• Version 1: Just the quote and video
• Version 2: “Hey, sis…” followed by the quote
• Version 3: “To women everywhere…” followed by the quote

The results were dramatic: Version 1 received 200 views, Version 2 received about 1,000 views, and Version 3 received over 10,000 views. This data provided clear guidance on which messaging resonated most with their target audience.

After testing, you can choose which Reel to “share to everyone,” making it visible on your profile. The other versions remain hidden unless you choose to share them as well.

Use DM Automation for Lead Capture

Rather than asking followers to “click the link in bio” (which she notes is less effective now), use calls to action like “comment this keyword” to trigger an automated DM with your link.

This approach allows you to:

• Capture leads while you're offline
• Focus on your zone of genius instead of constantly monitoring Instagram
• Maintain work-life balance while still driving conversions

When setting up DM automation, be careful with your keyword selection. Choose specific keywords or phrases that won't accidentally trigger a response. Marberry suggests adding numbers or combining words (like “episode66”) to avoid sending automated messages to people who aren't actually interested in your offer.

Popular DM automation tools include ManyChat and MobileMonkey, and features built into social scheduling apps.

Your Instagram Content Calendar: Maintain Consistency Without Burning Out

While consistency is important, Marberry emphasizes sustainability over frequency. “I would much rather you post less, higher-quality content and commit to showing up consistently in whatever cadence is sustainable for you and your team,” she advises.

Don't worry about finding the “perfect” posting time—if your content is valuable, it will perform well regardless of when you post. Instead, focus on creating a content workflow that you can maintain long-term rather than going all-in for a month and then disappearing for three months.

Start with a manageable posting schedule and add more as you become comfortable with the process. The key is building sustainable habits that allow you to show up consistently for your audience.

Other Notes From This Episode

• Connect with Michael Stelzner @Stelzner on Instagram and @Mike_Stelzner on X.
• Watch this interview and other exclusive content from Social Media Examiner on YouTube.

Where to subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube Music | YouTube | Amazon Music | RSS

✋🏽 If you enjoyed this episode of the Social Media Marketing podcast, please head over to Apple Podcasts, leave a rating, write a review, and subscribe.

---

Stay Up-to-Date: Get New Marketing Articles Delivered to You!

Don't miss out on upcoming social media marketing insights and strategies! Sign up to receive notifications when we publish new articles on Social Media Examiner. Our expertly crafted content will help you stay ahead of the curve and drive results for your business. Click the link below to sign up now and receive our annual report!