Building Trust in a Changing World: How to Make a Lasting Impact

Are you finding it harder to earn your audience’s trust in a world where skepticism runs high? Do your marketing efforts feel less effective as buyers take longer to make decisions and seem more resistant to traditional tactics? 

The rules of connection have changed, trust is in short supply, and it's reshaping the way people engage with businesses.

This article offers a practical guide to rebuilding trust in today’s trust recession. You’ll discover three core principles for building trust that lasts: focusing on context over content, using conversations instead of full automation, and prioritizing time-saving transformations over bloated value stacks.

Whether you're an entrepreneur or marketing lead, this article will help you cut through the noise and connect with customers in a way that inspires confidence and drives long-term growth.

Why Trust is Critical for Modern Marketers

Trust with customers has always been incredibly important for marketers and business owners. After attention, trust is the most powerful currency we have in marketing. Trust is essential for someone to give us their money, and we're all in the business of making money and selling our products and services.

What's particularly concerning is that we are currently in a major trust recession. The Edelman Trust Barometer provides concrete evidence of this decline. They've been conducting research every year since 2000, measuring trust across twenty-eight countries with over thirty-three thousand respondents. Their Global Trust Index shows we are at an all-time low compared to the past twenty-five years.

Sixty-eight percent of people believe business leaders lie to them—a significant increase from fifty-six percent in 2021. When asked about their trust in AI and comfort with businesses using AI, over eighty percent and seventy percent, respectively, expressed moderate to high grievance.

As business owners and marketers, we need to understand that we're entering the marketplace in a battle of decreasing trust. When trust is critical to making a sale, we must address this.

If people trust us, they will buy from us again and again.

3 Ways to Build Trust With Consumers

Consumers constantly sort businesses into three categories: 

• No, I don’t trust you.
• I'm not sure I trust you, yet.
• Yes, I trust you. 

Most of the time, when people first discover you, you fall into the “I’m not sure” category.

So, you must first convince them why they shouldn't count you out before trying to convince them why they should buy from you.

Google's report Decoding Decisions, Making Sense of the Messy Middle defines this messy middle as the web of touch points and evaluation between when someone first discovers you and when they buy from you.

This customer journey used to be clear: click, sign up, buy. Now, there's a much longer buying cycle because people are in an extended evaluation phase, figuring out whether they should listen to you, like you, and trust you before deciding to give you their money.

Most people take much longer to evaluate their options because businesses offer what they do to the same customer base. Businesses that are patient and take time to do trust-building activities will come out way ahead in the long term because they can stay connected long enough for customers to decide to purchase.

And when you get added into the “yes, I trust” bucket in customers' minds, and you don't do something to lose that trust, that customer will likely buy from you repeatedly. 

#1: How to Build Trust Through Context Over Content

Anyone can go to ChatGPT or Claude and generate content, but AI doesn't have your context, taste, perspective, point of view, experience, or knowledge of your customers. Using AI to generate content is a race to the bottom because everyone has access to the same information and rate of creation. 

The winning strategy isn't creating more content, it's focusing on context.

You need to prove to your audience that you are a real person who knows what you're talking about and has valuable insights based on experience.

Implement Show-Don't-Tell Marketing

Insights over information win every time.

Telling people you tried something in your business and sharing the results is infinitely more interesting than a social caption hook like “Here are five tips to XYZ.”

Instead, focus on what you have that nobody else has: experience, data, and split-test results that you can show your audience.A perfect example is Catttoni’s lead magnet. Instead of positioning it by saying, “Here are five ways to write a better subject line,” she highlighted the fact that she split tested over a hundred subject lines and then analyzed them to find the winners.

Share Substantiated Case Studies

A glossy avatar picture with text and a name makes people wonder if the story is real. Screenshots of actual conversations with customers, shared with permission, show transformation in a believable way.

During a recent live masterclass, people asked, “How do we know that these are real?” when case studies were shared. The solution was to invite students whose case studies were featured to jump into the chat and say, “Hi, it's me. This is my story. I'm real.”

#2: How to Build Trust Through Conversations Over Automation

When discussing one-on-one conversations with customers, the first question marketers ask is “How do you scale that?”

Businesses can replace their entire customer service team with AI, and they might save money on labor expenses, but what does this cost them in terms of trust?

Cattoni believes maintaining personal outreach is sometimes worth it, even if it's not scalable, because one-on-one conversations create more trust than anything else.

You don't need personal outreach at every price point. Extensive personal outreach isn't necessary for a $27 course. However, personal attention becomes crucial for higher-ticket items like a $10k mastermind.

Cattoni successfully implemented this tactic for her mastermind by eliminating sales calls, gatekeeping, and funnels in favor of a simple call to complete an application. Qualified applicants received a personal email from her with all the information about the mastermind and investment.

After sending the detailed email, the next step was to visit applicants' Instagram pages and send genuine voice memos: “Hey, I wanted to make sure you got my email. Sometimes it gets missed. I just sent you a personal invitation to my mastermind, and I'm here if you have questions.”

This simple human-to-human process had a higher conversion rate than any automated funnel.

Pro Tip: Personalizing your message by referencing something specific, like, “I saw in question three where you mentioned [specific detail].”

2 Tips for Scaling Personal Outreach

The key to scaling personal touch is mixing automation and personalization without trying to automate everything. People are starving for connection, and a little goes a long way.

Delegate: For busy entrepreneurs, delegation works while maintaining a personal touch. An assistant could say, “This is Jill, Alex's executive assistant. She wanted me to let you know she loved what you said about [specific content].”

Use Automation Tools: Asking prospects to “Comment X if you're interested” helps identify people who have raised their hand, then you can start one-on-one conversations.

#3: How to Build Trust by Prioritizing Time Savings Over Value Stacking

When people hear, “You're getting a hundred hours of content” or words like intensive or in-depth, they start to sweat, and their reaction is often, “Hard no, I can barely keep up with my to-do list.”

If people aren't consuming content, they're not buying again, and the only reason someone buys again is if they got results the first time.

Instead of adding hours of additional bonus content to your offer, think about tools that focus on time-saving solutions and transformation. Give people something that can cut their time in half and make things feel easy:

• AI prompts
• Copy-and-paste swipe files
• Checklists
• Laser coaching
• Personalized consumption paths 

The better you create results, the more trust you create, the more likely people will buy again, and the less money you need to spend on new customer acquisition.

Restructure Your Content Delivery

When Cattoni realized no one was watching the replay of the fourth call in her program, she went from four ninety-minute monthly calls to three calls plus a WhatsApp group for anytime support.

Then, one call each month became a connection call that's not recorded, giving her a way to show up live and connect with people.

Other Notes From This Episode

• Connect with Michael Stelzner @Stelzner on Instagram and @Mike_Stelzner on X.
• Watch this interview and other exclusive content from Social Media Examiner on YouTube.

Where to subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube Music | YouTube | Amazon Music | RSS

✋🏽 If you enjoyed this episode of the Social Media Marketing podcast, please head over to Apple Podcasts, leave a rating, write a review, and subscribe.

---

Stay Up-to-Date: Get New Marketing Articles Delivered to You!

Don't miss out on upcoming social media marketing insights and strategies! Sign up to receive notifications when we publish new articles on Social Media Examiner. Our expertly crafted content will help you stay ahead of the curve and drive results for your business. Click the link below to sign up now and receive our annual report!