Handling Negative Comments (TOTW: 3.11.13) (12 posts)

Topic tags: blogs, comments, SME, totw
  • I had another topic in mind for this week’s TOTW, but this morning SME published my article, 10 Mobile Apps No Conference Attendee Should Be Without.

    And when I checked it out, I saw something I had never seen before on one of my SME posts…NEGATIVE COMMENTS!

    So, I figured I’d ask you all this week about how you handle negative comments, whether on your blog, YouTube video, Facebook page or wherever.

    Do you engage or ignore? (I engaged.) Are you gracious or abusive? (I think I was gracious, but maybe you want to check for tone.)

    And, although I don’t have the ability to delete comments, do you delete comments? If so, what criteria do you use to delete them?

  • HI  @rich-brooks

    I think that so far – you handled this perfectly.  I know the feeling that goes through you when you read a negative comment – it is extremely unpleasant. 

    I would not delete unless the comment is obviously anti-social (racist, hate-ing, bullying, etc.) but answer in a positive manner – which you did already!

    Kudos!  You’re doing great in my book.  Forge ON.

    Eileen :D

  • i delete if  rude or inulting…and i dont  explain…..your  reply looked  good  but i doubt if it  changed the posters mind….i thought his point was pretty  weak .

  • I generally engage but mostly just to thank them for stopping by and taking the time to comment, I don’t usually try to counter the comments.

  • @supereb @annfurnivall @jake-hower
    I wrote a post a few weeks back that I knew was going to be controversial, and BOY did people let me have it. 
    I did my best to keep my cool even when people told me I was an idiot. I kind of invited it, as I went into their “den” (their groups on LinkedIn) and called them out. It was my most successful article from a “retweet” standpoint.
    I generally keep negative comments up unless they’re misogynistic, racist, homophobic, etc. I’ve come to realize that I’m not always right. Oh, the horror! ;)

  • Negative comments should make you smile. Someone thought enough about themselves and their opinions to share it with the world. And you, are the one that invoked their passion. 
    I agree with leaving comments up that are constructive or at the very least an intelligent point.I always trust the source more if there are negative comments and respect the author for talking the time to discuss his opinions with others.But it did make me giggle that people cared enough about app suggestions to comment.That just shows a powerful writer you are:) 

  • i just  deleted another one….i had a picture of a piece  of my inventory on our  facebook page… with the price…795$$…. and a  guy  posted  his  opinioin  about what it was and  said it should be  200$$….why  is  he  even on  my page??? i definitely  didnt want to  engage him in  conversation…. 

  • Hi @annfurnivall

    When it comes to price – only YOU can set the market value as you know what your market will bear. Good on you.  Heh.  

    Eileen

  • I use the “tone” of the thread to determine my response. Emerson Spartz an expert in virilty recently said “Make them angy or make them happy, just don;t make them sad”. Pet owners can be over the top. I’ve run two FB posts, one yesterday and one last last month. Fashion models using well taxidermied parakeets to excentuate the shot. WOW that really pisses people off BUT it gives the posts “legs” (virlity) When I try to soften the negative comments, I always thank them for their thoughtful comment – and I Leave them ALL up but I’m either shot down or ignored. 
    I’m seeing a total disconnect with content on Facebook. I got a lot of “how dare you endorse this………..” with the  taxidermied parakeets but no one writes the editorial staff at the Chicago Tribune about how dare they endorse murder because they printed a story of a murder. So at the end of the day, if a see negative comments actually pushing the post I go with it – knowing that web surfers have the memory span of a lit match. 

  • HI  @mitch-rezman

    SO true.  An audience of any type is so fickle.  Plus, when it comes to pets (animals in general) some folks are plumb nuts-o.  I can relate!

    Eileen

  • lol…taxidermied  parakeets  would  be  fun at my  store  but wow…putting it out there to avid  bird lovers   is  pretty edgy….

    i had a  litllle  group of old taxidermied    baby chicks   a few weeks  ago….  it was   kind of  gross and  very  fun… 

  • @E N Brown Foot note:I like “edgy” but I had to take the post down, a couple fans got so ugly I had to ban them – they started commenting on “Posts by others” “don’t buy from WCP they post dead parakeets”. Ironically When i responded with images of the Ornithology Lab at Chicago’s Museum of Natural History (they have one of the largest collection of taxidermied birds on the planet and I visit there for education and inspiration) and an Aunt who was a taxidermist that preserved 2 budgies under glass at her nieces request – I was called “sick” by some for engaging in this endeavor by the very people who take animals that normally cover 10,000 acres a day in the wild and they stuff them into nine square-foot jails for 70 years – which they consider perfectly normal. 
    Moral of the story? We don’t need background checks for gun buyers – all the government has to do is visit a bunch of Facebook fan pages and they’ll be easily able to identify all the whack jobs – problem solved :-)
    BTW @Ann at greenoak  birds preserve very well – cats do not (once cats stop licking their fur it dries out) 



Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!
Get your ad placed here!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageChris
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJameson
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Avatar ImageAlexandra
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Yvette Betancourt
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Chelsea Janke
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Kristy Henry
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Grethe Lu
Profile picture of