Speakers: Powerpoint vs. Prezi (22 posts)

  • Powerpoint has been dominating the presentation sphere ever since real slides went out of fashion. It’s a great tool, easy to use, and part of the Office suite. So basically, it’s the mainstream go-to presentation application.

    In the past two years, though, I have noticed more and more speakers using Prezi for their presentation. As one panelist once told me, “it’s like Powerpoint, but on steroids!”. I actually used Prezi for a keynote I gave in November, and it really wowed the audience – OK, it wasn’t just the presentation but also its content too :-)

    What’s your take, Powerpoint or Prezi? Which do you prefer and why? Any other hidden gem out there we should be aware of that is even better than these two?

  • PP may well have been dominating the presentation sphere but the phrase… “Death by Powerpoint” has also become common currency at the same time. Prezi is likely to keep your audience awake and attentive for a lot longer because of the rotation, zoom and other features keep you interested a lot longer.

    I vote for Prezi every time

  • Thank you for this topic Frederic  @fredericgonzalo   I have had success with PP and have very good templates to work with. I use them for speaking, webinars and teleseminars. Since I have a team that helps me create them, I will admit, they do rock. We also use Camtasia to bring them together. 

     But…I am always looking for more effective ways to communicate with my audience.  I had not heard of Prezi until today,  and now will look at that after your rave review and Rory’s. @roryramsden  Thank you for sharing this information!  

  • @roryramsden @randithompson Thank you both for your input. I, too, think Prezi is way more powerful than Powerpoint in helping deliver dynamic, living presentations.

    But I wonder, if you present to a crowd as part of a training, and you want (or hope) that people will take notes, how you can “share” a Prezi presentation. It’s only accessible online, or on desktop if you purchase the license. I don’t believe you can print a deck, as you would with PP. I guess that’s one disadvantage of Prezi.

    Othe than that, though, it rocks. Curious to hear what others may have to say on this topic…

  • @randithompson , @Frederic Gonzalo The key goal is to keep your audience engaged when you are presenting. Having a dynamic screen using Prezi resets people’s attention very minute or so. You can do this with PP too and of course Keynote but Prezi offers more… We usually give people a flash drive to take away… A small price to pay

  • @fredericgonzalo I’ve been using PP for so long, habits die hard. But you can prepare effective presentations with it, avoiding “Death by PPT”. I like that you can use Slideshare with it.

    That being said, it’s been such a habit, I have not looked at Prezi. I will have  to check it out.

  • @joanmuschampfagnani You coined it perfectly: old habits die hard. I also resisted moving to Prezi for a year or so, but now that I have worked with it, I have every intention to use it more often.

    Indeed, you raise an excellent point, that PP is shareable via Slideshare, which many people are familiar with as well.

    In any case, both have their pros and cons, it’s always a matter of how a presenter uses them. Still, Prezi has an edge, like @roryramsden mentioned, in that it’s a sure way to keep your audience engaged and hooked.

  • @fredericgonzalo For me I think it depends on how the tools are used. I’ve seen Prezi used and while it looks cool, I didn’t find it enhanced learning. In fact, I found myself confused with where the speakers were going. I also agree with the point about not being able to distribute slides.

    Powerpoint certainly can also be misused. Too many people create slides to say exactly what they plan to say instead of allowing it to be a visual hook and to provide complimentary content that keeps people engaged.

    You also need to know your audience. Demographics and learning style factor in.

  • @phil-mershon Absolutely agree! Not sure who once said this, but a powerpoint presentation (or any presentation given by a speaker) should never be as good by itself, i.e. reading the deck of slides, as when given by the speaker. In other words, in a Prezi just like a PP (or any presentation software), keep words to a minimum, emphasize on images and/or videos to keep audience engaged.

    Reminds me of the 10-20-30 rule, by Guy Kawasaki. Ever heard of it? A presentation should have no more than 10 slides, last no more than 20 minutes, and use 30pts font size for easy reading.

    More on this here: http://blog.guykawasaki.com/2005/12/the_102030_rule.html#axzz1jHb3bKXm

  • @fredericgonzalo

    I use Keynote when I have the choice, and PowerPoint when I’m forced to.

    Whenever I use Keynote someone always comes up afterward and asks “how did you make such a great looking presentation!”

    PPT has gotten better, but it’s nowhere near as cool. Haven’t tried prezi.

    I agree with everyone here, however, who says that slides should support your presentation, not compete with it.

    One of my favorite books on the subject is Presentation Zen by Garr Reynolds.

  • @rich-brooks I am not familiar with Keynotes, will look into it. Thanks for the feedback!

  • I think Prezi is fantastic, but it just takes longer to create a presentation. If you want to stand out and WOW your audience use Prezi.

    You can still give great presentations with PPT, if you got good content, good delivery, you’re good to go!

  • @fredericgonzalo– Keynote is similiar to Powerpoint for a Mac.

  • @fredericgonzalo @danhoward

    Yes, Keynote is similar to PowerPoint…kind of like it’s more beautiful, smarter, more-fun-at-parties sister! ;)

    http://www.apple.com/iwork/keynote/

  • @danhoward @rich-brooks Great, many thanks for the info. Wasn’t familiar with Keynote, but I just watched the tutorial and it seems like a must, now that I am on a Mac.

    Still, I will keep putting efforts into Prezi, as I believe it holds even greater potential to WOW audiences. At the end of the day, though, as was mentioned by many on this thread, it’s all about the presenter, rather than the tools. Or rather, both should complement for a powerful delivery.

    Cheers,

  • For a start-up, often times what tools you use comes down to cost.

    Powerpoint is free, while “Prezi is sold as a service, which means you pay an annual fee. The first 30 days are free, and you can cancel any time and will not be charged anything.”

    Their two paid versions run from $59-$159 a year.

    Prezi does have a free version, but it appears that your slides will have the Prezi Logo on them.

  • @warrenveach Hello Warren. Actually, I’ve used Prezi (free version), and worked great, and no logos of Prezi on the presentation per se – they don’t have “slides”. However, I am considering going with the 59$ option, giving more freedom and possibility to download and work from desktop, i.e. offline.

    But you’re right, cost is something to consider. Keynotes is also priced, at 19.99$ according to iTunes app store. These are small costs, though, in the big scheme of things, I find… ;-)

    Cheers,

  • @fredericgonzalo

    Hmmm…When I look at the pricing options page it says that “Public” users (free) will see a small Prezi logo and that it will be removed for the “Enjoy” and “Pro” users (Paid) and you acn add your own logos.

    Maybe I’m not understanding the phrasing properly and need to get an account for better understanding.

    However, it does appear to be a pretty good tool to use.

  • @rich-brooks haha…I know, I know I need to make the switch to a Mac! :)

  • @warrenveach Here is the link to the keynote presentation I did last November to an audience in Montreal, Quebec (Canada). I used the free version, by the way: http://prezi.com/qne58q7nphay/le-defi-de-linnovation-en-tourisme/

    (Sorry, but it’s in French, with a couple of english slides or visuals)

    Once the presentation is deployed, in full-screen mode or via a LCD screen (or other), I don’t believe there is any Prezi logo on there.

    Indeed, it’s a great tool to use. Takes some time and manipulation to fully get all the potential, but it’s no better or worse than Powerpoint (or Keynotes, I presume).

    Cheers and have a nice week-end!

  • @fredericgonzalo

    Wow! That is slick!

    I’m going to have to try that.

    I did see the Prezi logo when the presentation first appeared, but it went away as soon as the presentation loaded, so I don’t think anyone would ever notice.

    I saw it probably because I was looking for it.

  • @warrenveach Hey, we told you it was slick, eh? :-)


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .