Please do not spam us with your message ads! (52 posts)

  • @pronoya,
    @atlantarobin @mike-stelzner

    How about if I were to simply respond, “I believe I have a source for the information you were seeking. If you would like, I can PM it to you.

    I think a simple statement like that lets the poster know that I have knowledge regarding their inquiry, and puts the ball in their court as to whether or not to pursue it.

    Would that be acceptable?

  • @warrenveach I don’t think it’s spammy to include links to our own website or pages/profiles in our replies or dm’s. We’re here to support each other in our business ‘games’. I want to know your expertise, specialty and context from which your answering the question posed. It’s a way I can get to know you and your business better. I want to see your website and Facebook page… see if you use a Fan Gate, graphics, newsletter list. It gives me an idea of the expertise you have that I can utilize. Call it social proof. I go to peoples Fan Pages and read their posts and comments before I like their page and before I take their contribution.

  • @mike-stelzner  Thanks for banning the health product person! Unsolicited sales doesn’t belong here!

  • @warrenveach @atlantarobin @pronoya

    If someone is asking a question and your service is the answer, it is always appropriate to reply publicly.

    For example, “I need someone who can help me build out my Facebook page…”

    Your reply, “Our company specializes in this…”

    Alternatively, if someone asks a question that might not be looking for a service, but you make a connection, then I would private message that person and say something like this; “I saw that you were looking for tips on how to improve your Facebook engagement.  I happen to help small businesses as a consultant, in case you’re looking for outside help…”

    Both of these situations share one thing in common: contextual relevance.

  • @amyhallbiz

    Thanks for your comments Amy.

    However, in my case, trust me, looking at my fan page isn’t going to impress you with my online marketing expertise. We have to rely on 20 years in the business. That’s the hard part to relay on a facebook page.

    But, that’s what I’m here for; to learn from all you online marketing pros!

    We are making changes as we speak to the fan page, but it is still a work in progress.

    But that doesn’t mean we don’t know what we are talking about. :-)

  • @mike-stelzner

    Thanks Mike,

    I think that is probably the best answer to this thread yet.

  • @warrenveach  I checked out your fan page… I didn’t even know you can do the stuff you did with your landing page! Congrats! Are you converting people to fans?

  • @amyhallbiz

    Thanks Amy! I’ll take that as a serious compliment as I figured I was way behind the curve on fan pages.

    I’m trying different page styles on different pages. Hopefully, I’ll settle on one before too long.

    We started the page not to long ago and only had a few “likers”. I’ve been promoting it a bit more this past week and the followers jumped to about 50.

    More importantly, several took me up on the free prescription card offer, and a couple even made product purchases.

    It probably should be classified as beginners luck, but I’ll take it!

    Thanks again!

  • @warrenveach I’m old school and a late adopter… I just have a plain old vanilla fan page… I like the ‘zen’ factor. ;)   But I’m leaning toward putting up a fan gate… There’s a WordPress plug-in for fan pages now, so I’ll probably take the plunge!

  • @amyhallbiz

    Yeah, I was playing around on WP this morning and saw that plug-in. The disadvantage that I saw was that the WP plug-in was a little more DIY, whereas some of the fanpage apps are more point and click, drop and drag.

    The simpler the better for me!

    P.S. I stopped by your page and gave it a “Like”.

  • @warrenveach  Thank you for liking my page!  The advantage with WordPress is it should be easy to use in the long run… But we’ll see, I’m hoping to get my Fan Gate up by the end of the month!

  • @amyhallbiz

    Good luck, let me know when you have it up and running. I may have to ask you for help. :-)

  • I have a question.  If I found some advantages to G+ that absolutely nobody is talking about it, and I posted a link to a video explaining these advantages which led into a sales funnel would that be spam?

  • @mike-stelzner

    Thanks for your examples using contextual relevance as our guide in dealing with how we respond to requests for our paid services or to situations where our paid services could be the answer to someone’s needs.

    I encourage you to somehow preserve this thread. The more this conversation developed, the more helpful it has become. I hope everyone stops by to read this thread. It’s a keeper.

    Also, because I so liked the answer to your question, may I ask what SME’s policies are on quotes, attribution, citations etc. regarding materials, resources, member writings in forums, SME writings, etc.? I like writing narratives that visually illustrate problem-solution situations for readers. I have an idea in my head right now and would like to quote the answer you wrote about contextual relevance above. What are your writer’s guidelines for using source materials here? What’s allowed and what’s not allowed?

    Robin Carlisle

  • @alremetch

    Al, I would say that is likely not a good idea without full disclosure.  You should say “we have a paid service that might address your need and go here to see a video.”

    @atlantarobin

    Of course you can quote this :)

  • To me, I am not here to try and sell anything… I am here to make new friends, and to learn new things, plus if I am able to lend a helping hand, do that also.

    I can’t get my head around how some people can think throwing up some links (here, or any social network) is going to make someone interested in what they have to say!

    Maybe it’s because I’ve been in sales previous to being a facebook consultant, but spamming is to me like me contacting a would-be customer and before I say anything else to them, I just say ‘buy my product, here it is!!’ DUH wouldn’t get many sales, would I? I heard this quote: “People don’t care what you know, until they know that you care” Isn’t that the truth!!!! :-)

  • @randithompson Great post Randi!!

  • I have a question about the rules for these forums. First, my assumption is that if someone posts a link to a product for which he/she is an affiliate, he/she should disclose that relationship.

    Is that in fact one of the forum rules? 

    I’m asking because a particular member has posted a link (looks like an affiliate link) and recommended a product that looks a lot like a MLM setup to me . . . and this member did not disclose any relationship. 

    It may be a great product, but if it turns out that my purchase is lining this person’s pockets, I want to know. That wouldn’t stop me from buying—but I want to know what’s going on.

    Moderators, can you respond?

  • @pronoya @atlantarobin

    To me the answer is simple. If someone direct messaged me here in the forums asking about my services, I’d message them back inviting them to connect for a phone call. This is what I do anytime I get an inquiry no matter what the setting.

    If the person was serious in their inquiry they’d likely say yes quickly, the call would be set up and we’d get to know each other offline in a private setting. I know that I would not hesitate to private message someone here and ask for a connection call  . . . that’s partly why I’m here, to make connections that can possibly be taken off line at some point.

    @warrenveach if someone in a thread is asking a question that I can answer and help through my expertise I would answer the question and if I had a blog post or an article (written by me or someone else) that could further serve them I would include a link.

    Cheers,
    Stef

  • Just an addition to my post above. The link in question was indeed an affiliate link.

    @rich-brooks Can you comment on my question in post

    http://www.socialmediaexaminer.com/clubs/small-business/forum/topic/please-do-not-spam-us-with-your-message-ads/?topic_page=2&num=20#post-5310

    Thanks!

 


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .