Drupal vs, Wordpress? (13 posts)

Topic tags: Drupal, Wordpress
  • What would any self respecting forum be without the Drupal vs. Wordpress discussion.   @chrisloeser made a point that Wordpress is not just a blogging platform. Do you think it can be a viable solution as an all out CMS. ( not real sure what “all out” means :) )

  • 100%, absolutely!

    Hi Jason!

    I have a small interactive agency and we specialize in WordPress as our CMS platform. None of our websites look like they’re set up on WordPress, and all of them are so multi-functional and diverse, it’s just incredible!

  • @jasonwiser

    I’m not evangelistic about one platform or the other, as I believe that if you’ve got good designers and developers on your team you can make any decent platform (WordPress, Drupal, Joomla, etc.) sign and dance.

    We build almost exclusively on WP these days, whether or not the client has a blog. 

    So yes! WordPress is a full on CMS tool. 

  • @jasonwiser I used Drupal for a few months in a previous position. It was ok for posting basic text but I found it unwieldy for adding images. That’s my 2 cts.

    Now I use a generic CMS system to update my association’s website. If we add a blog later this year, I will consider using WordPress.

  • The general assumption is that Drupal is more robust. I have yet to be proven this is the case. So I ask this question everywhere looking for the real truth. Unlike  @rich-brooks , I am a WP evangelist. I started with Drupal, then began to experiment with WP a few years ago, now I will never go back. I too agree that WP is entirely capapable of being a powerful CMS. 

  • @jasonwiser  I too, sing the praises of WordPress! It’s easy to use, once you understand it. Easy to update content, and we all know Google wants the newest best content there is. Easy to modify and customize. 24% of all the sites being built right now are built on WordPress.

  • @jasonwiser As a web developer I have gained new clients who came to me because they could not figure out how to maintain the Joomla / Drupal systems that someone built for them.  I could barely figure it out myself! The WYSIWIG factor was SO missing. I get it that WP is not completely WYSIWIG, but the average site owner can log in, edit pages and add posts in WP without help. The same cannot be said for many Drupal and Joomla sites. It may be just as easy for us developers (although I do not consider that to be true myself) but it is much harder for the client.

  • @amyhallbiz yeah great to point out those numbers. 

    With get_post_meta and customized loop functions, you can have loops inside loops, multiple loops on a page, etc. And this is relatively simple. It is real easy to simulate the “nodes” that drive Drupal this way. And creating custom pages with many different customized dynamic content regions is a breeze. And have you really looked at the number of tables, out of the box for Drupal vs. Wordppress? Crazy huh?

  • I love wordpress and guess you know that this SME site with it’s clubs is a wordpress site. @jasonwiser

  • @jasonwiser Hey everybody, it’s always a great thing to be the first one disagreeing. So here I go. I think WP is not comparable to Drupal, because they are not meant to be used for the exact same thing. WP is an easy out-of-the-box blog CMS. It is built to maintain a simple news based workflow. You don’t need to have any programming knowledge to set up a site. WP is simply the best for blog based sites.

    Drupal, however, is, in my opinion, much better for bigger, more holistic, websites. Yes, Drupal needs much more customization. You need to decide about a wysiwyg-editor, you need to add fundamental modules, and you definetely need knowledge, in hmtl, php and css. But once you get there, Drupal offers the best workflow for maintaining large user groups with different access levels to content and backend, for maintaining a huge sitemap with different levels (WP is not built for multi level menus), for customizing your content in different regions on your site (WP does a sidebar, yes, but Drupal and Joomla have multi level regions built in). And – this goes at least for Switzerland, having four official languages – Drupal is much, much better in integrating a logic and consistent multilingual environment.

    For my web projects I choose WP for a news/blog-site, Joomla for small websites and Drupal for large projects.

    That being said, I herewith declare myself ready for bearing the blame :-)

  • From my experience(s), Drupal & Joomla are both too fat & take too long to load. We ran some splits, same 8 page site template… same servers… load times varied, but during peak usage (10:30 – 1) & (3:30 – 6) the same site took nearly twice as long to load with the drupe than it did with joomie… for giggles, we did the same thing with WP & it was like was like a greased pig, the other 2 couldn’t catch it! So we’ll be taking a hard look at getting all of our sites over to WP in the next few months.

  • @jasonwiser I agree with @ecumenix on this argument.  Drupal is an extremely robust system that comes with much more muscle than Wordpress.  It is a bit more sophisticated and not as easy to initially set-up as a Wordpress site, however the infrastructure, security and taxonomy that comes with Drupal is well worth the learning curve.

    As far as ease of functionality from a clients perspective, when we develop our sites in Drupal and “hand over the keys”, we do not give them 100% admin access, we minimize the functionality to exactly what they want to alleviate the headaches of all the bells and whistles, this has proven successful and most of our clients prefer to have the minimalist version of the Drupal CMS.

    I recently wrote a blog post on “Top 10 Reasons We Love Drupal CMS

  • Every technology should have its own Apple vs. Microsoft debates, and Wordpress vs. Drupal or Joomla is a perfect example. One side hardly ever converts the other. Each of these packages appears to be better under some user circumstances. Like Apple vs. Microsoft, the answer is ‘it depends on what you want to do with it and how much time/money you want to invest’.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Avatar ImageChris
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageJameson
Avatar ImageRobin
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Kapil Mudholkar
Mitch Rezman
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Deanna Viele
Profile picture of
Jose Damaso Ramon
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Ann at  greenoak