Dealing with Hateful Comments (23 posts)

  • Although this just happened on Facebook, I’ll start the conversation in this club because it could happen anywhere.

    I posted a thread on FB about what candy from your childhood you hadn’t outgrown. It was just a silly little question, but it got a lot of feedback. 

    (Mine’s Sprees, in case you were wondering.)

    After about 30 comments an uncle of mine who grew up in another time said what could only be taken as a racist comment on a nickname of a popular candy.

    I deleted it, as my personal profile is closely linked with my brand, but meanwhile most of the people who commented got an email with his comment.

    Outside of immediately deleting his comment and sending him a message that what he said wasn’t acceptable, is there anything else I should do? How would you handle it?

    (BTW, I don’t believe my uncle is racist, nor has he ever behaved in a racist way in front of me. He just said something that is completely unacceptable today, and to me.)

  • Rich,
    Gotta love those relatives that are from another time and like mine never knew the meaning of being racist. 

  • @rich-brooks  I think what you did should be enough.  Most people know you cannot prevent “unacceptable” posts.  But you deleted it immediately, so that shows your objection to it, and those that got the email will see that you did so.

  • @rich-brooks  I agree with @kimkline that immediately removing it was best.  If it were my own page or one of my clients, I would have taken the same action.  If anyone were to say anything about the comment, I would address it by saying that I thought the comment was inappropriate and it was removed.  

  • @rich-brooks Playing Devil’s advocate, could it have been a teaching moment? Responding with a ‘wow times have changed and I can’t believe that we ever thought that way’ (personally I would take the deletion route too). 

  • @rich-brooks I think removing it was the right thing to do, but think @kc_kreative has a valid point. You might want to simply let him know that social media often is not just a conversation between family members who understand and know him. You have a large “social reach” and people who do not know him could very easily take that incorrectly.

    Most of us probably have family members who unthinkingly (Is that a word?) say things that are rooted in the past; I know I do. I think I was related to Archie Bunker–

    More importantly is that some simply don’t realize they speak to such a potentially wide audience.

  • I think people understand that Facebook is more or less an open platform. You can’t control what people post. I wouldn’t stress about it. 

  • I think removing it was a good call, but I do like @kc_kreative suggestion.

    I don’t know what the appropriate thing to say would be, but if you posted a comment dealing with it head on then everyone would also get that email. And they would see very clearly where you stand. You could even delete your own comment after it went out.

  • Hello Rich @rich-brooks 

    My FB personal account is also linked to my brand so I don’t really chit chat all that much with relatives, although sometimes it happens.  A cousin just had a new baby grand-sugar and of course, that’s a very big deal to all of us.  Adorable child. At any rate, interacting with family is a big part of FB, so, unavoidable.  

    FB is different than a lot of other places, you pretty much have complete control over what happens and how you handle that will reflect on your biz acumen.  I know; I’m in the same boat. 

    If a relative is being unkind, cut them loose. I mean that.  For whatever reason, this relative has chosen to deface your wall.  What would you do if this was a stranger?  You’d boot them out, right now, without question, right?  No difference for a relative. IF they know this could impact your biz, then that person does not have your best interest at heart. 

    Or, at the very least, send a private message that tells him what he did (the comment) and why it was removed. I don’t think I’d send anything that goes out to everyone.  Since this fellow is family you have to take a slightly different tack. The fact that the comment was racist does matter however, you see this in the mainstream every single day.  Some racist jerk spouting their poison.

    And if you don’t hear from him, just mark it up to a sad/bad experience and move on. You know, you cannot please everyone.  It’s impossible.  We’d all like to please every single person; but OH!pinions are like… well, you know (and everyone has one.)

    This was mine.

    .02 – Eileen :)  

  • Maybe it’s a good thing to let people have their say. Sometimes they know things we don’t.

    I had an experience recently when a near and dear older relative started singing a song in public that by today’s standards seemed to be clearly racist.

    As he persisted in singing, I gave him the kick under the table and pointed out that he was embarrassing me. He said, “You’re being too sensitive. My fifth grade teacher taught me that song. She wasn’t a racist.” Frustrated, I answered, “It was 1938; everybody was a racist — now stop it.”

    I was upset for days. To prolong my agony, I looked up the song on the internet. I wanted to understand where the song came from and why a relative of mine would be singing it. I found it. It was a folk song made popular by Odetta. There were YouTube renditions of contemporary white singers singing it.

    I guess racism isn’t always what we, of this enlightened era, think it is.

    So, with this in mind, my advice would be: if it bothers you delete it, but be gracious to the older generation. Their experiences are different and can still teach us a thing or two.

  • @judithgotwald you make a valid point, but I would be discriminating about what I let slide by. If you know your audience then you will have a better understanding of how they might perceive it, not how it was intended to be perceived.

    Negativity attracts negativity, just like positive attracts more positive. As the leader, which if it’s your page you’re the leader, you are responsible for setting the tone and deciding what is acceptable and unacceptable.

  • @juleswebb Very true. But it’s also the root of censorship—which I suppose has its place. 

    I understand your concerns. I even share them—especially if a comment goes beyond obnoxious to offensive. 

    But even people who are positive can be wrong, especially if never challenged.

    Its tough being a blogger and having all this power. :-)

  • Hello all – as a relatively new FB user I have a couple of questions relating to the above posts

    1) is there a way to limit your relatives friends from posting in your News feed until you have approved it?

    2) Can this be done on a person by person basis, or do you have to do it through creating a list?

    3) I agree that deleting negative comments is a great approach, and sensitivity about tolerance and learning from different generations, but I would like to know what steps each of you take to protect yourselves, or monitor these types of comments on a daily basis.

    Thanks

  • @judithgotwaldThere is a gradient between censorship and focusing a discussion, it’s not an either or scenario.

  • I know. @juleswebb

  • @juleswebb – I agree with your assertions on this.  Touchy but once you know where to draw the line, it becomes a much easier task. 

    Example: I have a group at FB (very, very small membership - https://www.facebook.com/groups/ABHPnetwork/) but even with a small amount of members, you get negativity from time to time.  It’s hard to gauge, especially when you know the person or have known them for a very long time.
    What they say LOOKS bad but since you know the intent behind the words, you may be OK with the comment.  Still touchy at times.  I’ve moved the line a time or two. BUT since I have the power to decide, that also makes sense.    

  • @iamconsulting – Yep – that’s the thing to do. Agreed.  :D

  • Can I steal this post? I want to see if I get reactions to it… Love it.. who cares if someone doesn’t like it, they can ignore it. I would also delete it, but then message them about why? However I might leave it there, too see what happens after. I have heard that negative can turn into positive but you have to be there to react with what is going on. 
    @rich-brooks

  • @rich-brooks as you know negatives comments are a great way of turning a negative into a positive situation. Thereby saving face, showing that you are responsible and that you care.

    But every now and then you will get someone saying something completely irrelevant , irresponsible and insensitive.  In this case the delete button is more appropriate. Besides leaving such a negative comment that will only cause more trouble out there associated to your profile can do more harm than good.

    Guilty by association. :(  

  • I’ve always found FB to be a family / friend environment with the exception of business pages. It’s good practice to keep these accounts separate to save you from personal embarrassing moments that only friends and family can put you through.
    In spite of taking those precautions, there is always a level of risk. If nobody reacted to his post, I would have deleted it too. If there were comments then I agree with @kc_kreative and @juleswebb to deal with it head on.

  • Funny! We work so hard to get comments. Then we struggle with what to do with them!

  • I think this illustrates perfectly why I have a Facebook account that is strictly used for business and one that is for friends and family. I think that there needs to be that separation in pages. Alternativly I think that your situation could have been better handled by simply responding to the comment in a positive way. “Uncle, times have changed and that is no longer an acceptable nickname” would have showed that you didn’t like the comment- thus placing you in a more positive light. All too often, we become “delete happy” as it is the easiest way to deal with things quickly.

  • I think this illustrates perfectly why I have a Facebook account that is strictly used for business and one that is for friends and family. I think that there needs to be that separation in pages. Alternativly I think that your situation could have been better handled by simply responding to the comment in a positive way. “Uncle, times have changed and that is no longer an acceptable nickname” would have showed that you didn’t like the comment- thus placing you in a more positive light. All too often, we become “delete happy” as it is the easiest way to deal with things quickly.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Avatar ImageChris
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageJameson
Avatar ImageRobin
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Jose Damaso Ramon
Ann at  greenoak
Profile picture of
Nick LaBran
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of