Advice Needed! How and when do you fire a client? (17 posts)

  • I have a client that we have been trying to develop a logo & website for but each time there is a revision there is always a new issue.  First they ask for 1 thing, then something else and then back to the original.  I specifically have not entered into any contract at this point knowing it is an interior designer & may be difficult to satisfy them.  Now they are frustrated with our services – should I continue to try and complete the on-going task or cut ties??

    Please help, any advice would be helpful!!

  • No one wants to lose business. Re-set the playing field by re-agreeing to scope of work with clear parameters.  And have sign off stages so they can’t go back and tweak something they already approved without re-negotiation to fees.

    If re-negotiation at any stage is required, be clear as to what the extra charges will be and have them sign off on that too.

    If this doesn’t work, maybe it’s best to walk away. Sometimes it happens. Be professional and clear in your communication, while respecting your own value you’re bringing to the project.

  • I probably have fired more clients than I still retain;  and I have gotten fired a number of times as well. As Daniel said, give it your best shot but realize at times you cannot be all things to all people.  You must weigh the potential gains (revenue, referrals, etc.) as versus the potential loss and aggravation in a Ben Franklin methodology – list all the +’s on one side of a piece of paper along with all the -’s on the other side

    If and when you get to the end of trail (a salesperson’s final statement) close, it is sometimes better just to walk away.  As a left brained, logical thinker, I find it very, very difficult to relate at times to right brained, artistic types.

  • @mikey @danielmckean

    Thanks so much for your quick responses!  I feel distressed and not in the place to make such a big decision, so I cancelled our contract meeting for tomorrow.  I would like to do a new round of revisions as a last shot to see how she communicates.  She is disappointed that I have not signed a contract but I’d rather be able to walk away in the end if I need to than have a ball & chain strapped to my ankle for the next 15 years.

  • @melissaholmes  I always like to “sleep” on testy decisions as well.

  • Whenever I’ve said to a client, ‘this just isn’t working. Let’s call it a day” I have never regretted it for one minute. You know when you have someone you can work with and when you don’t. Listen to your gut. It knows you. I’m telling you this because, of course I’ve learned the hard way, determined to make something work that isn’t the right fit. It’s only hard the first time, and it’s not even as hard as you think it’s going to be. your client may know that it’s not working too.  Best of luck!

  • John Tabita just finished writing a series of articles for sitepoint.com called Putting a Stop to Abusive Client Behavior

    You might find some useful information within them.

    Good Luck!
    Jules

  • I like to ask, “what’s the worst that could happen if I do this (or don’t do this)?” @melissaholmesInteresting article.  @juleswebb

  • @melisaholmes  While contracts are best for setting clear expectations, at the end of the day, contracts are only as good as the people who sign them.  Written contracts open the door for endless interpretation when serious disagreements arise.  One can always claim that you’ve breached part of your contract, and it is expensive and stressful to defend yourself, even if it’s obvious that you are compliant.

    Feel fortunate that you’ve discovered her unstable behavior early on in the project.  You already know how she communicates, and presenting a new round of revisions is not going to change that.  It is difficult to turn away work, yes, however, sometimes it is the right business decision and best for your mental health.  There is plenty of good business to be had.  If it were me, I would not allow the relationship to continue.

  • Whew! what a relief.  Later on I tried to digest some of the things she was saying, so I will have to see how the next couple days play out.  I did explain to her that she can get her logo elsewhere since she complained about sketching on her own when she is paying someone to do it for her (post 3 previous designs).  Another web developer had previously dropped her & now I’m wondering the other side of that story :/

    Thanks for all the input & I will check out that article above ^

  • Thanks for the link!  @juleswebb

  • Consider that this might be a communication issue.  The customer is not understanding what you are going to do……or…….you may not understand what the customer wants.  So a contract and maybe a drawing can set the expectations.  There are two issues here…….the client’s expectations and your intentions.  You have to get them on the same page.

    That being said, I have a boss who can’t envision anything unless he sees it on the paper…..so when he remodels one of our stores….I draw it out on Sketchup.  Then he changes it and changes it……ever after they start building.  He’ll go back and reword something he created two weeks ago.  I must have patience.

  • @melissaholmes

    Life is too short to spend any of it with people who cannot make decisions and stick to them. Approval of design work can be agonizing to the designer when it appears that what you’ve slaved over, somehow, just is not quite “it” for the client. 

    Depending on your fee structure, work out the bugs.  This is never a pleasant process, no matter how nice, considerate, and kind the people in question are in their dealings with other people. 

    I would want to say give her the “boot” but what if this is as good as it gets? Have your other clients been more cooperative, approving and praising of your work? Is this woman disagreeable or just disagreeing with your concept? 

    Try to look at this from her side – IF she is not satisfied with your design,WHY isn’t she satisfied?  There could also be a personality clash here, in which case, you would be better off without her business as she is not going to find your work to be satisfying, no matter what. If this is the case, get out now, while you can.

    Without knowing the parties involved, it’s hard to give real advice but sometimes OH!pinions can help us see things a tad more clearly.

    And sometimes disagreeable people are just a part of the business at hand.

    Eileen :)

  • Thanks for all of the support & input.  Basically there was a lot of misunderstanding as to what she was expecting from our services.  Although in the beginning of all of our projects I explain how we handle each step, she is expecting what a design firm does.  She offered extra money to compensate but I had to decline the business because our services just don’t match up with her needs/wants.  She was very upset and started getting a bit insulting so I’m glad I found this out before I bound any attachment. 

    I haven’t had this issue yet with other clients but we are learning new techiques & plans to serve our current and future clients better.  I will have to amend our Quote structure and our website project process will have to be made much more clear.

    If anyone else has input in those areas I would be happy to hear – I am just relieved that this serious problem is closed and we can move on!

  • Hi @melissaholmes,

    I’m so glad you found your way out of this mess. You know i’ve been a client myself for 8 years and i will admit, clients can be a pain.

    But there are a few learnings i had during my years as a client.

    1. Time is money. Neither sides want to waste any more time than is absolutely necessary.

    2. Clarity saves time. Which is why we wrote nearly 5-8 pages of a brief alone and had atleast 2 meetings before we started expecting any creatives or outputs from our agencies. Yes, some people think its too much – but when you do decide to partner with someone, the best way to get great work out of them is to help them understand your business goals & constraints.

    3. Have a payment plan that motivates both sides.

    In my experience, typically once an agency or service provider won a pitch for a website, they got 20% first so that they could begin the design work. Once design was presented & finalized, we paid them the next leg of 30% to get the website templates in order. And then when they finished the whole website and it was “live” – they would get the next 50%.

    I don’t know how you feel about such a payment plan. But I noticed, that the moment a client is forced to pay some money upfront, they begin to take the agency’s time more seriously.

    This also works for you. At each stage of delivery you are assured of getting paid. If for some reason, you and your client part ways – atleast you wont walk away feeling cheated of your time & efforts.

    I hope this helps you in some way,

    Good luck,

    @ShipraSaid

  • @melissaholmes glad you’ve been able to resolve the situation. Sounds like you made the wise decision. Heartache with a client makes work less than fun :(

    I don’t have a written quote structure or project process, but I do have a project questionnaire that helps me assess a projects needs. You’re welcome to use it as a reference to create your own project questionnaire. It’s the result of my own researched of 100′s of project questionnaires and articles on project questionnaires I found online. 

    It helps weed out people who aren’t serious or are looking for a deal.  And since many people don’t know what’s involved with building a website it can help them find out what questions they should be asking themselves. 

    Good Luck!
    Jules

  • @shiprasaid @juleswebb

    Thanks ladies for the feedback and suggestions!
    Julie – I did notice that our preliminary questionaire does help to see who is actually into a project.  I like the way your’s is so I will definitly be updating ours.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .