Was I too rude? (19 posts)

Topic tags: Spam removal
  • I run three FB Pages for three golf courses.  In the past couple of weeks, I’ve had a related business (golf ball retrieval that sells used golf balls) like and begin posting links to their products on our pages.  I’d been deleting the links but today I finally deleted and banned, then I sent a message to their page from my personal account:

    I’m not sure who you are but spamming golf course customers is going to get you banned from Facebook if you don’t watch out. Most pages that are kept up don’t allow spam ~ we report it as such. If you actually do work for our courses, it would be wise to call your course contact and request that you be UNBANNED from our pages ~ and ASK if you can post links to your products. This is pretty standard business procedure in the world of social media . . . if you don’t want so many spam reports that you end up with your page deleted by the media owners (Facebook, in this case). 

    I don’t mind helping a business partner out, but the people that we have do our ball retrieval are not (to my knowledge) known as Absolute Golf. I’ve never entered a check or cash payment to this company in our books ~ so, again, call your course contact (there is only one and you should have his personal cell phone number ~ you will never find him in a clubhouse and employees never give out a cell number). Request that you be unbanned and allowed to post links on our pages. Until I come home and he tells me differently, I will have to keep your page banned from our pages due to the continuous unapproved links that you have been posting.

    Dedi
    Thorne Hills
    Thorne Brothers at Lilac
    Old Town Golf and Sportland

     What do you think?  Was I too rude?

  • I’m really scratching my head here but how is this even remotely rude in any sense of the word? You don’t swear, you don’t threaten, you simply point out facts for page use and standards combined with what they can do to correct themselves.

    Your page is not a free posting ground for them: it is for you. If you wish to allow someone else to post on your page, that’s fine, however, you are not required too. It makes sense that you’d allow your business partner to post on your page – it would build a stronger relationship and could be leveraged into a tighter connection (and perhaps better rates)!

    So, no, I think that this message is spot on, and not rude, and I’m betting that Absolute Golf has seen a lot of messages like it.

    Good luck!

    Jason

  • @dedimasonI think you were direct, honest and kind. You demonstrated a willingness to partner, but were also clear about your course of action and the problem with this company’s actions.

    Bravo!

  • Thanks @jasonreilly and @phil-mershon!

    I was so angry when I wrote that I hear my anger when I read it, which is why it sounded rude to me.  Having parties that can’t hear my anger read it and say that it doesn’t come off that way makes me feel better :)

  • I detect professionalism….no anger at all.  Very well written.  Thank you for sharing.  Great reference to have if / when I have similar issues. 

  • I think you did great. It could have been much much worse! But honestly, you voiced the reason you blocked this user, and you gave the steps in getting back to good standing. You’re looking out for your client/company and you did your job the right way. I agree it’s a good reference, so thank you for sharing.

  • Good job on that. Very professional is you ask me..

  • @dedimason Kudos!!  You were clear, concise, and not at all rude!  Would love to hear what kind of response, if any, you get!  

  • @kimkline ~ They did respond a little while ago and it made me feel better.

    “Thank you. Sorry that you considered it spam. I will not send out links on Facebook anymore. You were the first person that has informed me of this. I was just trying to grow my business and thought spam was computer generated emails. Have a nice day and if I can ever have the privilege to work at your course give me a call at [number removed]. I appreciate you informing me that I was doing something wrong.”

    I was glad to see that they did not take it as rude.

  • good  for you  dedi…..and maybe they didnt know   … idiots  tho….lol

    i would have made sure it  wasnt   your  golf ball guy…and  just  banned them and  sent  a  shorter  ….quit  spamming us, or  nicer, did you relize this is  spam and  can  get you in  trouble?….

    ……  i have had that  happen  on our page too….and have   seen the advice to do it   from a few of the  social  the gurus  too!! 

     its  horrible and i  always   consider it  unwanted and  spam…….

  • @dedimason  I think you were correct in doing so.You were in no way rude, but very direct and straightforward.  I had to do some similar a month ago on the Basset Hound Rescue of AL website as one person posted a comment that was derogatory to rescue, not just ours, and 87 people jumped on with comments to which the original person replied.   Protecting a Facebook page and the client brand is critical stuff. Good for you.

  • I think it was very nice of you to even send a message, @dedimason and let them know that this was rude behavior on their part.  Many people have this impression that they are “getting the word out” about their business when they are really spamming.  

  • Thanks for a nice letter template to use for future spammers!  I also loved this letter from Jack Daniels to a copyright infringer – talk about polite!!! http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/9427111/Jack-Daniels-sends-worlds-most-polite-cease-and-desist-letter.html

  • This was very polite in my eyes, I ban 10-15 people/pages per day and do not send any message at all lol.Spammers should know what to expect after all :)

  • yepp, like @jasonreilly asked, how is that rude? 

    If you need a less on rude, I can put something together quite quick. :)

  • your letter if fine…but I still don’t get it…why do you ban them, if you are not sure that they are business partners or not? you are asking them to tell you that…why didn’t you check the records? just because you haven’t heard about them, doesn’t mean they cannot be present at your golf course…because in case you are mistaken, it could be a bit embarrassing…
    also, do no forget that social media is all about making business contacts and raise awareness…maybe they are not that savvy in SM, thus the spamming, but it could be a lucrative business deal for your golf course in the future….
    I always ask the Why question…”it seems that you are doing self-promotion too many times on our page, are you aware that our FB page policy does not allow that?” … by the way does your page have a house-rule or page policy tab?

  • @szaszabox You makes some good points. Still  @dedimason ‘s letter was appropriate and based on the response, informative. Seems like there might be an opportunity to partner with this organization in the future.

  • @dedimason

    Not rude, just too long.  Folks like this do better with 3 sentences.

  • @pbcsky I agree! I am not even sure I would have bothered to answer, so a shorter reply would have done fine. But good for @dedimason to have taken the time and effort to come up with such a professional reply. Kudos!


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Avatar ImageChris
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageJameson
Avatar ImageRobin
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Jose Damaso Ramon
Ann at  greenoak
Profile picture of
Nick LaBran
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of