Topic of the Week 12/17/12: Social Media posts in response to tragedy (15 posts)

  • First of all, I just wanted to say I am devastated by the event in Connecticut.  As a mom of 2 grade school boys, I can’t fathom what the parents and community are going through right now.  So tragic. 

    But as people behind social media icons and companies, how should we respond to these tragedies, if at all?  Is it appropriate to post anything or should we remain respectfully silent? 

    We had an interested discussion on the Social Media Examiner wall with a wide range of opinions (including many who thought I was crass for even posting the question which was not my intent at all).  http://www.facebook.com/smexaminer/posts/10151279524149383

    Did you post anything on Friday or over the weekend?  Do you plan on doing something later?  Wondering where people are at.

  • I didn’t post at all.  I wish I could have, but I worried that someone would take it wrong.  (Like some of the people on your FB post.)  I don’t know anyone who isn’t heart-broken and praying for the parents, family, and friends – as well as the community.  Now I’m concerned that our FB friends might think the opposite - we didn’t say anything so were uncaring. 

    How do we move forward – follow our originally planned posts?  I received an email from one expert who blogged today that unless we were directly involved, we should not send any of our scheduled emails or social media posts for several days.  Another person I admire sent a blog post with a beautiful and touching quote. 

    What do you think?

  • I personally believe that a Fan Page should at least acknowledge in a neutral objective way what’s going on in our daily life and in the news worldwide or local. It shows that the page/brand/service is close to its community. I also try my best to not leave any posts open to discussions because then it will turn into a fight and disrespectful comments. I don’t want to be deleting comments that may offend some people because the whole point is for them to interact right? Well, some people take it to the next level and it’s just not classy. I saw that a lot during election time!  Hope it helps.

  • @andrea-vahl @asearfoss @systale, very simple answer: if it were you and your kids in that situation – and thank goodness it wasn’t, would you want strangers talking about things they only heard about in the media or would you want privacy? 

  • @johnkelly, Actually, if someone was posting something caring, then yes I would appreciate it.  We do that on our personal Facebook pages all the time – often about or for someone we don’t know at all except through a mutual friend.  

    I guess each administrator just needs to know their audience and try to gauge their reactions as best as possible.  If there is any question, then stay silent. 

    @andrea-vahl, what is your take on it?  The majority of the bloggers out there seem to be suggesting not to say anything at all and make sure you change your scheduled emails and posts.  However, the posts that meant the most to me as a follower were ones that just had some heart-felt words or quotes. 

  • @asearfoss, agreed and well-stated. Send well wishes, that’s it. Opinions are off limits in my mind.

  • @johnkelly @asearfoss - Totally agreed with your last post. A post just showing caring, well wishes and leaving personal opinions out, it’s the best and safe way to go! A lot of things can get out of context and out of control easily in this social media world.

  • @asearfoss I do agree with that.  I think definitely turn off the marketing messages (and there were some people who lashed out at people who didn’t turn them off) but a true human response to the tragedy felt good to me. 

    There were some people who worked it into a blog post but I don’t think that’s right.  I did also see some people posting as their page very political statements. 

    @asearfoss I think you can still say something.  This is all still so heavy on our minds that a heartfelt post would still be received well in my opinion.

    But I think it really does depend on your audience.  I think if you have never revealed your personal side from your brand before, that it could be strange for your audience to see that side come out suddenly.

  • i did one or 2 minimal on my personal page and none on my   busness page…. it   is heavy on   my mind like  everyone…but  i didnt  want to go there on the page…couldnt  find the right words, didnt want to seem to   be  jumping on the  wagon…wasnt  sure if it  would  even  be  appropriate…

  • @andrea-vahl It is okay to put out supportive posts in moderation. I used some quotes along with a respectful tone. Today I mixed in some advertising – marketing – PR curation on the tragedy; however, I vetted EVERYTHING to make sure it was respectful.

    Monday’s Tweets:

    • Good morning. The country continues to recover & our thoughts are with the families. However, our tweets will be (mostly) normal today.
    • How should your news station cover the tragedy? http://buff.ly/U49WFS via @Radio_Ink
    • RT @Adweek: Media missteps in Newtown CT coverage. http://buff.ly/Trx6VA #SandyHook
    Friday’s Tweets: 
    • We leave you with: “Hearts rebuilt from hope resurrect dreams killed by hate.” ― Aberjhani, The River of Winged Dreams
    • Our hearts go out to the parents & families of the victims at Sandy Hook Elementary. It is a terrible tragedy for them & our nation.
    Facebook:
    • ¡Buenos días!. It is a mixed Monday as we’re still recovering from Friday’s tragedy. While our hearts continue to be with the families, our posts will be of normal content today. 
    • Our hearts go out to the victims and families of the Sandy Hook school tragedy. “Hearts are breakable,” Isabelle said. “And I think even when you heal, you’re never what you were before”.” —Cassandra Clare, City of Fallen Angels

  • I did post an initial reaction to the event on Friday when it happened, but had a hard time even posting anything non related over the weekend. Everything I thought seemed so trivial compared to what had happened. I don’t know why, but in some way silence was my own way of mourning.

  • I took the indirect route in my posts. I just didn’t want to get too specific, mainly because there were plenty of those posts already, and I did not think the people who started to turn it into a political football were acting appropriately. But the small things around the house no longer seemed to be things to take for granted. That, I shared.

    Kids are yelling and causing an unholy ruckus upstairs. Sounds pretty good.”

  • I’m with  @johnkelly . If I was ever remotely involved in anything so devastating I would appreciate comments on the official FB or memorial sites, but nothing else.  I felt a bit sick to be honest when I saw lots of blatantly shareable/likeable content going up on business FB sites.  How can it be right to profit even marginally from the tragedy? 

    I was in the middle of a bunch of Twitter posts when I heard the news.  I stopped posting anything for the whole weekend, and started again on Monday.  Like  @dawnchitwoodrivers I couldn’t face engaging in anything trivial.  

  • We prefer our page to remain a “hole in the wall” to escape to – I watch a lot of news and coverage (as most news events today) is getting oppressive. I, like others sometimes just want to be comforted. 

  • I didn’t make posts on any of the pages I admin, or my personal page for that matter. I didn’t think it was appropriate, especially being from Canada and having such strong opinions about US policies that need to be addressed but that I don’t have a right to share at a time like this.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .