Multi-Page Strategy – When should you have more than one Facebook Page? (11 posts)

  • I have been asked recently by a couple of clients about the wisdom of creating multiple pages for their organisation to reflect the need of the different client groups.

    I would be interested to hear from others in the group about this issue? Is it always best to stick to one main Facebook page that covers the different consumer groups, or is it better to create multiple Pages which talk directly to each type of audience?

    The danger of having multiple accounts in my view is that the Facebook presence may become too fragmented. This issue must be quite common with multi-nationals and I would be very interested to hear what others think.

    Alan

  • When I first started with Facebook Pages, I created several off my main personal account – My Company Page and then several pages which highlighted my Individual Services, i.e. Social Media Marketing Specialist and others.  I found when I invited business contacts to my main Business Page, they willing connected but as I added specific pages, for whatever reason, they decided not to join those additional pages.  I think in part, many people don’t want to Like every page they see – they just want the one company and not the individual  services.  So I stopped promoting the individual pages and everything  I post on my Business Page deals with a diversified number of posts.

    I think that if a large Company with individual “divisions” might be able to do this more effectively.

    Take an example like General Mills Canada (since I am from Canada) has many divisions – Nature Valley – Big G Cereals – Green Giant – Old El Paso.  So they might set up their page names like – General Mills – Nature Valley and General Mills – Old El Paso, etc.  That would identify their main corporation but have each “brand” on a different page – I think as a FB user, I would be inclined to join the pages I would have an interest in hearing about like Nature Valley and Green Giant rather than just the main General Mills page.

    I am a small operation so I can effectively communicate with my connections for all my services but a big Corporation may be more effective in individualizing their Brands.

    Just my opinion…

  • I agree with @dcoville001.  The decision about making multiple pages really depends on the type of business you have and how big your business is.  A lot of the larger corporations have multiple pages to allow the user to connect with a “sub-brand”.

    In addition, many authors will create a main page about them, but have a second page which highlights their latest book.

    While determining whether to create multiple pages, the company needs to realize that they will also have to monitor and run those pages.  They need to make sure they are staffed well enough to give each page their undivided attention.

  • I usually say stick to one page. Creating multiple pages not only creates more work, but it also creates confusion for your audience searching for you on Facebook “Which one do I fan?”!

    I think that if you have a welcome page addressing the multiple divisions/audiences and states what types of posts you can expect from the page than one page should be sufficient.

    Also, you can always create multiple welcome pages or multiple tabs, having your different audiences land on that particular tab as their welcome, or having a specific tab about that particular division.

    In general the more streamlined your social media efforts the less confusing. I have seen banks have multiple twitter accounts and those were used effectively but not so much with Facebook.

  • Thanks everyone, some great advice. I like the idea for large companies of keeping the parent brand.  @joancrocker I was very interested in your idea of multiple landing pages (a solution that occurred to me too) but I can’t see how you can determine which of your welcome pages people see when they visit your Page, so if you have figured this out I would love to hear from you.

    As far as I am aware, you set the landing page and all Facebook traffic will go there. How could you go about (for example) directing traffic from the US to one landing page and traffic from Germany to another one? My client has a network of international distributers and wants to be able to direct traffic to these country-specific distributers.

    Any ideas on this would be fantastic!

  • hmmm… @chatmarketing I’m not sure if you can set a default for particular visitors based on likes/interests/demographics.

    But, you certainly can set up different Facebook Ad campaigns targeting those demographics and have those particular ads go to the appropriate landing page.

    I will look into it a little more to see if there is a way. It certainly would be interesting to test out and possibly really valuable.

  • Thanks for you help  @joancrocker much appreciated! I have been speaking to my client again today and I think they are going to opt for a single welcome tab which lists the territory contacts. At the moment the ads are only planned for the USA and UK so there are only two contacts that will be needed.

    If we decide to run adverts for the german market as well, I think we will need to revert to plan A and have separate landing pages for each country. The difficulty there will be having multiple tabs all called ‘Welcome’ (unless I can figure out a way to customise the app name as it appears on the wall).

  • @chatmarketing  There would be no way to set different landing pages but you could advertise and then set the advertisement to go to a particular landing page.  In the advertisements, you can choose an exact landing page other than the default for the ad traffic to go to.  Then maybe your main landing page could be something likeFrom Germany?  Click here:  link to German landing page.From France?  Click here etc.

  • @chatmarketing I know I made two pages. One for my company and one for my brand. @dcoville001 Is right in my case. Yes, it is more work and will cost money if you have to hire someone, but there’s a reason a lot of companies have pages and their products have their own page. For example. Rovio Mobile has their page, AND the Angry Birds page. Also if you have more than one brand like they do you wouldn’t put a racing game on the angry birds page. I hope this makes sense. Thanks and good luck!

  • I have a client who is an author who has 2 pages.  One is for her brand, and one is her Author/Speaker page (to cover her books when they come out).  As her social media manager, I can tell you that it’s a complete pain in the tuchas.

    We are constantly having to try to build a following on two pages, and come up with different content for each day, so if you have people following both pages, they won’t have all of the same info.

    If I remember correctly, Guy Kawasaki discussed this at the FBSS ’11, and he was sorry that he had set up more than one page too.  You have to be committed to maintaining more than one page, and responding to messages/info on each page.

    Just my two cents.

  • Thanks for the great advice everyone – I am learning so much with this forum!  @andrea-vahl do you know if it is it possible to rename the welcome tabs so you could have for example ‘Welcome USA’ or ‘Welcome UK? That way it would be very easy to know which ‘welcome’ page you are directing specific ads to. I assume you can test the link on the ad at the Preview stage, so even if you can’t customise the name of the tabs, by trial and error you will link to the correct one.

    Karen, @projsocial I watched that webinar too with Guy Kawasaki when he was saying that he wished he had never started another Facebook page for his new book, for exactly the same reason as you mention in your post.

    I do however agree with @dcoville001 that in the case of a very large brand that serves different territories, then it is possible to have multiple pages but branded with the parent company too. These companies would have the resources to maintain separate pages locally. 

    I had a client recently that was a university and they are maintaining several pages, one for alumni, one for current students, international students etc but they were finding it very difficult to co-ordinate, so in this case they would probably have been better sticking to the one page.

    Thanks again everyone for your comments!


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .