Just because a FB Ad didn’t work once doesn’t mean it won’t work later! (22 posts)

Topic tags: facebook ads
  • Just passing this along from my own personal experience.  Last summer I ran quite a few ads for the courses.  The ones that got the most clicks were the ones that had pics of the course ~ those with golf carts in them performed drastically lower.

    Right now, Michigan courses are closed for the most part.  Yesterday I started 2 ads, same wording, same landing page (on Facebook).  Right now the one with the golf cart picture is outperforming the course pic by an 8:1 ratio!

    If I hadn’t tried using both pics again and just gone with the results from last summer, my ads would be getting VERY LITTLE response. 

    Obviously, golfers have the ‘itch’ and are ready for courses to open . . . and my golf cart picture is playing the tune they want to hear~

    Just because it works one way once, doesn’t mean that it won’t work the opposite pater.  ALWAYS test ads!

  • @dedimason That’s great! Split-testing is a great way of running ads.

    Also try using people’s faces. They seem to attract attention.

    And, never run an ad longer than 2 days without changing it – that’s when you get maximum impact.

    Cheers!
    Russell Allert

  • Thanks for passing that along @dedimason!  Always good to hear what’s working out there!

  • @dedimason and  Andrea Vahl  I had a problem trying to run a Facebook course but there was no way i could get that approved other than changing the wording to online marketing course and remove the pic of my FB course. Does anyone know how to get around this as to promote and name what type of course it is instead of a general name like online marketing which can be anything.

  • @bertievg ~ Hopefully Andrea has a good workaround.  I market local businesses, so I haven’t had this problem.  I do know that it has to do with having Facebook in the name or description.  You might have to word it around social marketing specifically designed for business pages . . .if you get my drift.

    Adrea has probably run ads along this line ~ since she’s one of the best I’ve seen with Facebook Marketing :)

  • @Dedi Mason

    Agree – Thanks for sharing

  • Why does the name @Dedi Mason not hyperlink for instance in the post i have just send?

  • @bertievg Bertie, I do not know the answer, but I do know the workaround ;-)   Instead of typing in the name you want to reference, scroll up to the post they made and click on their screen name in the top right of their post. That will cause it to be added to the comment box, along with whatever hidden formatting it needs to make it work.

  • @abigailgorton

    Thanks got it!

  • @dedimason @russellallert  Thanks for the great tips

  • @russellallert  ~ Change it in two days even if it’s not at a frequency of 10 yet?  My best performing ad has run for a day and is only at a frequency of 3.1.

  • @dedimason Hi Dedi

    My first question: why are you so fixated on the Frequency measure? And why is 10 so important?

    Russell

  • @russellallert ~ read it somewhere along the way . . . just don’t remember where.

  • @dedimason Ok.

    I would ignore that stat. All it shows is how many times people have had the chance of seeing your add (on average).

    The stats you want to focus on are:

    Clicks – how many people click on your ad
    Connections – how many people Liked you page due to the ad
    CTR – Click Through Rate
    and Spend – when you are working out how much you spent to get each connection.

    To get that dollar value, simply divide the number of Connections you made by the amount of money you spent when the ad has finished it’s run.

    With regard to the CTR, if you achieving over 0.025 when you first start out you are doing pretty well. The higher this number, the better (generally speaking) as it measures how many people clicked on your ad verses those who potentially saw your ad (Campaign Reach).

    But the most important measure is how many Connections you are making. And how much they are costing you.

    Keep a spreadsheet with each ad’s stats and you will see over time which ads that are performing and which are not.

    Hope that helps!

    Russell Allert

  • @russellallert Great advice, as always, Russell. Cheers!

  • @russellallert ~ Thanks!

  • @fredericgonzalo @dedimason No problem! Any time. :)

  • There was some research recently suggesting that Facebook ads work because even if we don’t consciously click on the adverts, we do notice them and subconsciously align ourselves with that brand, with a subsequent uptick in purchases of that product.

    Here is the url of the full research http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/662069 but I’ve summarised it on my blog (the previous link) if you’d rather that.

    It might work, but it makes tracking effectiveness pretty darn tough.

  • @adigaskell ~ That’s actually why I’m running them right now . . . we will open for season on April 1 officially and earlier if it’s warm enough.  If locals see my ads enough, our courses will stick in their minds as soon as it’s warm enough to get out the and chase that silly little white ball though acres of land :)

    Golf is such a silly game . . . that’s actually tough to play (I know, I suck at it)!

  • Good write up @adigaskell. Impressions, frequency and consistency leave a mark on the sub-conscious with latent results then timing comes into play.
    Good strategy @dedimason

  • Of course it’s one thing being able to measure all of that in laboratory conditions, quite another to measure it in the real world.  I’m not really sure how you’d do it.  If there was an upkick in sales, how could you attribute them to Facebook versus something else you’ve done?  It’s a tricky one.  The traditional metrics used to measure an advert (things like click through rate) don’t do well at all on Facebook.

  • @adigaskell ~ For us, I post ‘short term specials’ on Facebook.  For example:

    18 Holes with cart for $18 this afternoon only when toy tell them you saw this one Facebook!  Posted Saturday February 18, 2012

    Give me a way to see if our Facebook marketing is doing us any good in the store.  Of course, it doesn’t show me how many people are coming in at other times because we’ve kept ourselves in their minds, but it does give me something concrete I can show Daniel.  If I’m at a course and it’s dead there, I post a Facebook Short Term Special to try to drive business in ~ then I call the other 2 places to see how their business is and whether I should post short term specials on their pages too.

    Any time I can drive people in at a dead time and get his register ringing, Daniel is happy :)


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!
Get your ad placed here!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageChris
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJameson
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageAlexandra
Avatar ImageAndré
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Markus Mueller
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Grethe Lu
Bunda Dewie
Profile picture of
Deanna Viele
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Catherine Tatum
Candice Carter
Profile picture of