Is Google+ for Business and Facebook Just For Fun? (15 posts)

  • There seems to be a growing opinion base that states that Google+ is better for business than Facebook Pages.

    If you’re on both platforms…
    1. How do you differentiate the content that you are curating on each?
    2. Do you have a system that helps you decide what to post where?
    3. Which is your favorite and Why?

  • Honestly, some people have better success on Google+ than on Facebook and vise versa. However, because Facebook has been around longer and because there are more loyal fans already on FB, it’s really hard to go to Google+ and to create different content for it. 

    Each social media platform I have and that I recommend for clients, is to create different content for each platform. While they may share the same blog post, it’ll say something different on Twitter than on Facebook. I post a lot more on Twitter than on Facebook because Twitter is a much quicker timeline than FB. 

    At this point, I see Google+ really working for video and pictures and at this time, I don’t have too many of those yet. I say this because from what I’ve seen from my friends on Google+ and from others I’ve interacted with, photographers do really well and pictures in general get a lot of comments. 

    So, in conclusion, Facebook is still the leader when it comes to better business. :)

  • @Morgan Barnhart agreed that FB is the leader but, in your experience, does Google+ attract a different client base?

  • In Slovenia G+ is not atractive. Main % of users are there only becuase of curiosity. So facebook is number 1!

  • interesting to remember that not all sites appear the same in different countries! need to consider is your business is international @leopoldpanovi

  • @deairby at the moment I’m working only for Slovenian and Croation clients. For them g+ is not atractive at the moment. For some international brands is perfect because they can get fans or followers a lot easier than on facebook. G+ is in fase of growing and everything is new – people are follow brands for no-reasons so you can easily get fan-base. And also if you are active with content you can get gut followers :) But Slovenian followers are not enough active – most active people are in the same industry as me :)

  • @roryramsden Even though it is rumored that G+ had 65 million users by end 2011 and they are poised to reach 400 active members by end of 2012, I have yet to see a mainstream move, at least here in Canada, and more particularly in the province of Quebec (where I live and work).

    Facebook has a strong foothold, and remains the key go-to player for brands who want to reach their audience, since that’s where their audiences are!

    Seems like G+ appeals to early adopters and geeks, but until it reaches the masses I would suggest companies stick to FB while testing the grounds with G+ with a minimum presence, trial end error, and see what sticks.

  • how does google+ work better than facebook for video and photos?@morganbarnhart

  • @roryramsden So this doesn’t slip into ye olde “which is better” debate, I thought I would answer each of your questions directly:

    1. How do you differentiate the content that you are curating on each?
    Google+ is, and will be more so, very important for SEO as search becomes more and more personal. So it is worth getting in now and building your brand page up, so you rank better with those you connect with.

    For one client, I’m looking at using Google+ to post summaries of blog posts (as a sort of teaser) and then linking to the blog from there. I want to see exactly how much influence G+ has on SEO when if comes to the keywords I use.

    I am also playing around with video as well, to see if it helps rankings on YouTube (which is the second largest search engine in the world – after Google).

    I am using Facebook for the same client as more of a conversation piece and community-building tool.

    2. Do you have a system that helps you decide what to post where?
    I do have a plan as part of my larger social media plan (check out this post I answered on having a plan) and I think it’s important to do this as each social network is different and will help you in a different way. No site is better than another – if you think like that you will limit your options.

    3. Which is your favorite and Why?
    I personally love Twitter, as it allows me to network easily with heaps of different people from all over the World. But, like I said before, it will depend on where your cutomers are, what your business is all about, what you are used to, what sort of media you want to publish, etc.

    Hope that helps, Rory. Let me know if you have any further question.

    Russell Allert

  • @roryramsden Just came across this insightful post on Jeff Bulla’s blog, which sheds some good info with relation to this topic:
    Will Google+ Replace Facebook as the King of Social Media

    Enjoy! ;-)

  • @deairby It doesn’t necessarily work *better* than Facebook at pictures and video. It’s just the trend which has seemed to happen. I see and hear a lot of photographers saying they have had huge success their Google+. 

  • do you agree with the idea that google+ is for business and fb is for personal stuff? @morganbarnhart

  • @roryramsden If you google which social media platform is better, you will find a few articles that say Facebook is the only platform you need without question for business. The other ones add no doubt but Facebook is as essential to businesses as a phone number or email. Google it you’ll be surprised. Now that’s not to say forget the rest but if you want an order of importance I woulda say it totally relays on your business. Video bloggers would put YouTube as #1 same with people who make money off of YouTube. Where as most others would put Facebook as one. If your business requires a professional profile or resume LinkedIn may be your #1. I can’t think of an instance where Google+ would ever be a #1 (yet) its too new and doesn’t have half of what Facebook has (yet). Twitter by sher numbers is better than G+ (for now) because of potential in the number of users. Give Google some time they will over throw twitter they just need to straighten out their platform and add more features.

  • @Russell Allert @Soundgate Studio Inc  @Dea Irby @Morgan Barnhart
    @Frederic Gonzalo Thanks Russ for a comprehensive response which lays out the definitive position in my view.  Facebook is king for the moment. Twitter is a hyper responsive network for connecting to people on a one to one basis. G+ cannot be ignored especially as we will probably see integration with Youtube shortly… and yes I have videos there too. They should all be in your mix and drive traffic at each other with your blog being the center of the matrix.

    Incidentally, Images [and posts accompanied by images] and videos stimulate more response on FB and G+

    I’m upgrading my blog to include G+  sharing buttons now

  • @deairby I wouldn’t say Google+ is necessarily better with photos and videos but with the tagging I feel the SEO algorithm may be better. For me the key for using G+ is knowing the way it may be accounted for in the Google SEO algorithm. Also, I have found the loading time on G+ for me has been much faster than Facebook.

    For me @roryramsden it has been important to include G+ as part of our Social Media strategy for each of our partnership programs. While adding another place to post can seem time consuming it has been helpful for us to reach different prospects as well as generate relationships with related businesses that may be beneficial. 


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .