I was offered $450 app to force people to ”like” my page – should I? (19 posts)

  • I hope everyone is well.

    As some of you may already know, I’ve been obsessed with finding a way to make people have to click “like” before they can see my facebook wall. I’m not sure it’s a good idea, but I’d like that option.

    Well, my research and questions have put me in touch with an SEO firm that is offering to develop for me a ”forced-to-like” facebook app for $450, a one-time charge.

    Is this a good idea? Will people resent my page if they are forced to like it?

    Thanks in advance and best of luck,

    Tasgola

  • I do not suggest a “forced-to-like” app.  The whole point of social media is to be open with your followers/likes/friends.  

    When I first visit a page I will take a look at the Welcome page to see what kind of thought and effort the page owner put into their page.  I will then hop over to the wall to see if what they are posting is interesting to me.  If it is, I will then like the page.  If it is not, then I leave.

    If you force people to like your page just to see your wall, then a good number of them could also “unlike” your page.  Then you have invested $450 just to see people jump ship.

    Provide good quality content and authentic communication and your page will grow.

  • Thanx Lisa, My answer to Tasgola is almost the same as yours.

    I can guarantee you 100,000 likes to your page , but can’t guarantee one of them to come back to your page . That’s the point.

  • @tasgolabruner I agree with what’s been said.  I always look at the wall to see if the posts are useful before I Like.  If I couldn’t see the wall or if I had to optin to some App, I wouldn’t click Like.  I’m not even sure how this app would work because I think it would have to be an App with permissions since Facebook Pages are public by default.  

    Is there some way you could achieve the same purpose?  Have your best content delivered by e-mail that they would have to opt into but good teaser content on the wall?

  • I concur.  It takes time to build your “likes”.

    Long story to short.  When a while back you had to have 100 Likes to get your Vanity URL – a personalized URL like mine –  https://www.facebook.com/AlternativeOfficeAssistance rather than a long URL with a bunch of endless numbers, there was one weekend where one person started a page where we could all go and interact with other Businesses to Like each other’s pages and all of us attain our Vanity URL.  That was a crazy weekend.  We almost all reached our magic 100 and more.  On that weekend, I met and connected to many businesses I never would have met otherwise.  I wrote a blog post about it at the time:

    http://www.alternativeofficeassistance.com/social-media/what-really-happened-on-facebook-this-weekend/

    I’m pretty sure that because I consistently share my content and others on my wall on a regular basis, most of it is of interest to those who joined me on that weekend – I have lost very few of those connections.

    Like the others here who have taken the time to give their opinion, I would be very unlikely to Like unless I had a chance to see their Wall and decide for myself.

     

  • @tasgolabruner the quick answer is – I would not take that route because it is about engagement not numbers.   

    Quite often people obsess over the numbers like they do on Twitter. If one is going to obsess then it should be an obsession on how to build quality content that customers (fans) will engage with by clicking Like and/or Share so that what you have posted will go to their friends and possibly friends of friends.  

    Building quality numbers and generating interaction is truly a multi-faceted approach. Besides developing quality content, you also have to reach out and learn what your customers really want from you. Use the Questions feature on Facebook as a starting point to drill down and find out. However, make it a fun activity where possible. 

    Reach out to your biggest advocates through email and/or newsletter campaigns and let them know that you are on Facebook. Be sure to let them know the benefits of joining you there. Think content on everything that you send out and that includes your emails and newsletters.
     
    The human mind quite often works on the mentality of ‘what’s in it for me?’, because people just don’t have the time to waste. They want solutions, fun, an escape. I don’t know which applies to your customer base, only you know that. :)  

    Good relationships in life are earned and developed over time. The same applies in increasing people on our Facebook business pages. Remember, we want real talking people not numbers. :)  

    The advice that @AndreaVahl will provide this group will be invaluable. As a writer for Social Media Examiner and co-author of Facebook Marketing All-in-One for Dummies we have a great leader. :)  

    If anyone in the group is new to Facebook marketing, I do suggest you read Andrea’s book. I am a BIG reader.  

    Wow, I think I just wrote a mini blog post. See, this is what happens when you awake at 3:30 in the morning and can’t go back to sleep. :)  

    Cheers,Donna

  • Aww, thanks @donnagilliland!  You could totally turn that into a blog post :)  Great advice.

  • @tasgolabruner to enforce what was said above by @tasgolabruner

    As shown by the Twitter-powered political revolutions, power is shifting to the masses–and businesses need to understand the same thing is happening in their world, LeBrun said. Old patterns of customer interaction, such as making people wait on hold, aren’t going to be acceptable in the new business reality, he said. “Businesses need to line up for customers, rather than expecting customers to line up for business.”
    Companies must embrace enterprise social media in 2012 or be overrun by it, says Marcel LeBrun.

    Offer something of value on your social media channels. The evidence is clear in this article: The Major Disconnect Between Brands and Consumers When It Comes to Social Media | Social Media Today

  • You can go on Fivver and get thousands of “Likes” for five dollars, but what is the point.  You want people to like your page because it has value for them.  That will give you more credibility.  If they think you have something to offer them, they might turn out to be clients.  I want my targeted audience to “like” my page because it is useful to them.  There are enough ways on Facebook to have that happen, but it takes time and a lot of great content.

  • Chalk up another vote in the consensus column!  :-)

    I am fairly new to social media management/marketing myself, and I also get a little frustrated over slowly building numbers. But I get MORE frustrated when I can’t find the right hot buttons to get my fans engaging. To me, the quality of good engagement trumps quantity every time.

    As for forcing likes, I can tell you from my own viewpoint: if someone tries to force a like or a contact address from me before I know what his/her business is about, I move right along. My thinking is, if the person feels I need to be forced into giving up my information, or compelled to like a page, there mustn’t be anything of true value there.

  • I also don’t think forcing a like is a good idea (although it is tempting!).

    There are many ladders/shoutout pages you can join and see if they are of interest to help boost your numbers, but it is all about engagement and posting content that will give the reader/viewer value and want them to like or share what you have posted.

  • My page is about to hit 10,000 fans and I haven’t harvested any of them. I agree with what the majority have said here. Focus on engaging and responding and the interest will follow.

  • This is a topic near and dear to my heart.  I was recently at an event and their was a person there who has a company that for a fee will get fans and likes for their page.  We had a pretty good debate going on, whereby I was echoing everything that is being said in this stream.  What I found interesting, however, was that his clients were the big guns like Nike, Nissan, etc.  He convinced a person who was their to take him up on his service.  She has 8000 fans, however, when you go to her wall she has 3 posts. Unfortunately many clients feel that the number of fans speaks volumes, rather than the engagement level and other important factors.  

  • I would instead create a FB custom page. Here are 10 apps suggested by Social Media Examiner:How to create a custom facebook page

    I agree also with much of what is being said here.  Use the fans/likes as potential customers but that doesn’t happen right away.  It’s important to get the like, but its just as or more important to then continue posting great content to engage your customers, encourage conversation, then down the road when they need your service, they already have a relationship with you to then “remember” you and hopefully you will then get the sale :D

    I think the majority here is saying No, do no spend the $450.

    Heather :D

  • Hello! Forced likes are an all around risky move. If people want to check out your business or products etc. they can’t. When fans like a page is is basically an investment of trust and interest. They feel they can benefit by keeping track if your page. These people are the people you want to attract as “fans”. If you ask them to like the page before they even see anything you run the risk of: 1 people turning right around, when they otherwise could have been a potential customer. 2 Having them like the page but being put off by the fact they had to like the page to view it. So view your page already with an impression that is not favorable. Imagine walking down a street and all the stores have blacked out windows. The stores won’t allow you to look at anything without first coming through the doors and walking around. It will be annoying right? My point is people need to “window” shop on social media as well. On Twitter you may see a persons posts a few times through someone you are both following before you decide to follow them. Same idea. Someone comes by your page, they may not like it the first time around but if they come by it and see it again then they are returning and chances are, gong to like it. Use your Facebook page updates to measured your traffic. It’s such an incredible feature for businesses. Use the information in those to keep track and tweak thing accordingly.I really hope this helps!Good luck and Take Care!

  • Wow, thank you, everyone, for your immensely helpful responses! I really appreciate them.

    I apologize for the delay in thanking you (the holidays, work – you know how it is.)

    I’m going to go through your responses in detail and will likely come back with questions.

    Tasgola

  • @dcoville001 I like what you said and totally agree: “It takes time to build your “likes” “ 

  • @tasgolabruner What business are you in?

  • Is there even posible to make app which force fan to like your page if he want’s to see your wall? I don’t think soo.

    My suggestion for you is to use normal fan-gate wellcome tab , where you give to them some information or gift which only fan can see. :)

    And like everybody says the content is what it’s matters.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Avatar ImageChris
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageJameson
Avatar ImageRobin
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Kristy C. Cartier
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Katie Robinette
Becky at RemZzzs
Profile picture of
Brianna Mallory
Profile picture of
Tim Wilson
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Ashley Williams
Profile picture of