Buying Facebook ”friends” (23 posts)

  • I am in charge of my company’s social media sites and we are relatively new within the online world. I came across a site where you can buy Facebook page likes. Do you think this is worth the time or effort? And if we decide to go through the purchase, how do you think this will affect the business, if at all. The price is cheap for people to like the page I just wanted to see if it would even be worth doing, and what type of outcomes it would have for our online traffic.

  • I would steer well clear

    If you want to build your FB fans quickly there is no substitute for paid targeted traffic based on demograghics and geographic location. It;’s then down to maintaining engagement which is another story altogether.

    There’s no substitute for quality

  • Hey @matthewoneill

    I agree with  @roryramsden; besides, there are plenty of golden threads in this networking club that helps you go from a new company into an engaging community.

    Buying ‘Likes’ is like purchasing cardboard people for a party that no one showed up for.

  • @matthewoneill Never never never never never never  Never never never never never never  Never never never never never never  Never never never never never never  Never never never never never never  Never never never never never never  buy Facebook Likes.  
    Seriously.  Never.

    I did it one time to see what happened with a test page.  What I got was fake weird Likes from Egypt, the mid East, (not that there is anything wrong with those countries, it just wasn’t what the ad promised) and countries you never heard of with people with no friends.  The ad promised “US only quality likes”.  Don’t do it.  The people won’t be engaged and most likely aren’t even real people.  
    I like your quote, @thatsocialdude  Buying ‘Likes’ is like purchasing cardboard people for a party that no one showed up for

  • @thatsocialdude That is an epic analogy lol. Buying Facebook likes is like buying a sandwich that only comes with the buns. For me there is no sense of pride or achievement if you pay for people to Like your page. Knowing my company/produt and my personality (on social media) is what’s attracting people gives me a sense of accomplishment! Not like in World of Warcraft where you get something new and it’s a false sense of accomplishment cause you really havn’t acquired anything in any world that matters. A real sense of accomplishment. Knowing you are an asset to a company or a brand is very self fulfilling. .. In my opinion and experience at least .. @matthewoneill

  • Thanks for this topic  @matthewoneill  I would also suggest not purchasing fans.  As @andrea-vahl said so well. They are NOT targeted. I have a client who tried this.  She focused on the companies that do target.  She found they did not….  All you will get is a bunch of empty profiles that are not real.  Or, a list of 1000 people from a third world country.  I suppose if people are just looking to increase their numbers…instead of building them, that this would make the numbers bigger. 

    @roryramsden  I agree!   Facebook and Google ads are much more effective and bring in real people who are interested in what we have to offer.

    @thatsocialdude Love the idea of “purchasing cardboard people”  That is exactly what they are.  Unreal!

    @sgsrecording  I agree.  The feeling of accomplishment is what I like.  I like knowing that my fans have come to me because of what I have to offer.   Even if it is from ads, at least they are there for that reason.

    .

  • kudos to what everyone is saying here

    you will get more engagement from 10 people that have liked your site organically then from 1000 people that have been “bought”.

    try not to get too caught up with your facebook “like” figure.  everyone knows what its like to have a low figure, but dont feel compelled to abnormally boost it so visitors think its a jumpin place.

    i wrote a blog post some days ago about where to advertise your facebook page.  have a read, it should give you some tips in getting your details in front of your customers.

    top 10 places to advertise your facebook page

  • @dextereugenio Thanks for the awesome link it does have some really good tips.

    @randithompson The “buying” of likes is more about getting numbers that is how I saw it.  I understand everyone wants a core group of fans but doesn’t the idea of having more friends make you more likely to show up in any (including Facebook’s) SEO? 

    And I think about how many people you have already friend requested me on this site alone, which I’ve accepted all of them.  I just created this account and I already have 15+ friends?  I know nothing about them, who they are, or what they do, but I still friended them to get a larger network. 

    Do you guys and girls do the same thing and if so isn’t that about as useful as the “cardboard” likes?  It just shows to others that you are a compelling person to engage with and therefore increases the likelyhood to be friended/followed/liked.

    @sgsrecording is a prime example…do you actually know your 500+ friends or did you do it to increase your exposure?

  • I will echo what everyone else said about not buying likes with an example from one of my clients. 

    Although I repeatedly told her not to buy likes, she insisted that her business wouldn’t look legitimate unless she had over 1,000 likes on her page. 

    Prior to the purchase, she had 600 fans and about 150 (25%) were actively engaged (liking, commenting, sharing). 

    After the purchase, she had about 1,500 likes, but still only had 150 engaged users since most of the purchased likes were from Eastern Europe and her business is 95% local to the Denver Metro area. Now she only has about 10% of her total fans engaged. 

    Since Facebook’s Edgerank algorithm takes into account the % engagement, her qualified likes (600) and her engaged fans (150) now are less likely to see her posts on their walls. 

    Her likes, comments and shares decreased by about 50% after she purchased the likes and now it’s a long road to recovery because she has to find a way to re-engage people and get more of them actively using and commenting on her page. 
    One other thing to note is that Facebook’s analytics become less useful when you buy likes. The demographics and other info can be very useful when creating an advertisement or understanding your audience and purchasing likes skews this. 

  • @matthewoneill I like to friend everyone because we are here to network, learn and share experience. The idea is to learn about the peoplesnd their businesses over time through the forums. If I have the wrong idea about SME I apologize, someone please correct me.

  • that’s a very strong point @lindsayhunt

  • @lindsayhunt That is a good point about your analytics and insights!

  • Hi @matthewoneill I will not repeat everything that has been said in this important post. I think the point is clear.  Just to let a thought: What are the objectives of a company for being part of Social Media? Things are done to obtain a result, so what would be the results of having a community of people who are not interested at all in the products or services offered by your company. It would be pointless if done it this way.

    Good luck and for sure after reading all these opinions you will make the right decision. 

  • @andrea-vahl @lindsayhunt  A great response to buying likes.  I never thought about the edge rank angle.  So many pages look so lonely with less than 100 likes.  When I’m visiting a new page if it doesn’t have many likes I think it is half baked or abandoned.

    About buying likes, aren’t a lot of big commercial enterprises doing this.  I see lots of ads where somebody says they will give a dollar to a charity for every like.  Would this create the same situation where you have fans not really engaged and it will damage your edge rank.

  • @alremetch, I think it depends on where they’re advertising the page with the charity donation and how they’re attracting people to the page.

    There’s nothing wrong with giving an incentive for people to like your page. Some do it in the form of a coupon, free eBook, etc. I’ve found that a Facebook Ad coupled with an incentive to like the page works well for attracting new fans. 

    The problem with buying likes is that you’re almost always purchasing unqualified likes from dummy accounts, often in foreign countries. With the donation to charity, you’re still attracting real people who have a much better chance of engaging with your content. 

    Ultimately, I think people (like my client) are impatient and want shortcuts without spending any time. Building your Facebook page (or any social media presence) takes time and you’ll get much more out of it in the long run if you take the time to build your page the right way. 

    There are ways to speed up growth with advertising or contests + advertising, but to me it doesn’t matter how many fans a page has if the fans are engaged. Some pages with 1,000+ likes may have infrequent posts and others with 300 may have people commenting, sharing and engaging. I always visit the wall to see the types of posts and interactions there before liking a page. 

    If you’re interested, I created video blog post about how to increase your Facebook Likes since many of my clients were asking about it!

  • short answer NO 

  • Here’s a good article on growing your fan base virally.

    http://socialmediatoday.com/fixcourse/421283/how-virally-grow-your-facebook-fan-page

  • I’ve got to agree with everyone here, and emphasize this point… What’s the point of Social Media? If it’s Relationship Marketing, then having empty numbers means nothing.

    Stick with quality growth, in the end your ROI will reflect a stronger business!

  • I have to agree with most the people on here.Buying facebook like from anywhere other than actual advertising is a no no.They really are fake profile or even if you do find a one with real users you are unlikely to ever get interaction from them. They will be the sort of person that like any and every page and never interacts.You might be new to the facbook game but hard work and genuine fans will pay off a lot better.Just remember if a real fan comes across your page and it has 1000′s of fans and no one is interacting with your posts/content they will wounder why or think something is wrong and possibly not participate or like your page themselves 

  • Even tho everyone allready advised you against it and my posting could seem just another voice in the crowd, I decided to join the discussion, because I think we can not put enough emphsys this enough: buying Likes is a big mistake!

    What is the reason for your social media presence? Do you want to add more visibility to your brand? Buying likes will only decrease it. Your edgerank will drop and less people that are actually interested in your brand will see your messages.
    Do you want to drive traffic to your website? The likes you bought will not generate traffic. Worst even, they will hurt it (efgerank again).
    CRM or reputation management? Again, no help from the likes you bought.
    If it is SEO you are interested, it seems to me you are turning to the “dark side” of it. Watch out, Google might catch on and it will penalize you.
    Not to mention that it is a really shady business. Do you want to get mixed up in it?

    IMO, it would be better to try some patience and grow  your fan base. GIve them quality content, keep them engaged, organize some events on your facebook page, put on some contests… There is a lot of (free) good advise on the net on how to do it. and there are great companies that deal with social media and inbound marketing that offer free ebook and whitepapers. Also, follow the discossions on this subject on Twitter and you will find a lot of usefull chat.
    If you want to invest in it, it is better to invest in Facebook ads and in contest.

    A question. Have you set up pages for your brand on Twitter, Google+ and LinkedIn? Depending on your filed, more social networks could work for you (StumbleUpon, Instagram and so on).

    I tryed to keep this post short, hope it is helpfull. If you still have question, feel free to DM me and (as much as my free time will allow it) I will try to help. Or just ask here :)

    Have a great day!

  • If you are working on a project where client specifically want to see quantity of fans not the quality of engagement, go for it. I have already faced  these kind of situations where success metrics is only no of likes.

    Explain your clients what are the pros and cons of buying likes, be transparent to them and do what business sense demands best for the situation.

  • @sudeep I think in these cases it fals to us to explain to the client why he or she is making a mistake. Just as, if they ask for a house with no roof, an architect would explain why it s not a good ideea. I agree now that there are some clients that just don’t want to listen. And yes, they do what they want with their money. But those are bad clients. It is easy to say in some cases you have to turn down a client, but… It is something to consider. He will only hurt his business and, possibly, yours.

  • Yes @gabriel exactly what I was trying to say. Tuning down a client is the last option, few agencies strictly follow their ethical guidelines for business promotion and they simply do not care what client is paying for, but certainly their numbers are meager.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!
Get your ad placed here!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageChris
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJameson
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Avatar ImageAlexandra
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Van Pappas, CFP®
Profile picture of
Moin Shaikh
Profile picture of
Sandra Spanish Hairstylist
Profile picture of
Ann at  greenoak
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Kapil Mudholkar
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of