Are Fan Pages Dead? (22 posts)

  • With Timeline launched last week for pages many people are panicking. I’m doing a webinar later today on the topic “Are fan pages dead?” and I’m curious to hear what reasons you’re hearing from people that think fan pages are no longer useful. 

    would love your input. 

  • @scottayres why  would  anyone say that?   wow .. i havent seen those discussions…hopefully i  dont know  what you mean  by  fanpages….can  you  clarify that for me ? 

    ……  our  business page  has   posted about  3   times  since  changing over and   i dont  see a  downward  trend….they have  brought in  about the same amount of   interaction…

  • When I say fan page I mean a Facebook business page. And yes many are saying fan pages are dead. And there are many that are freaking out because the changes mean a complete change in how they market.

  • thanks  scott….seems  like a pretty  fast   judgement…..  i sure hope it doesnt   end up   being  correct…

    …like i  said   it hasnt  been that way for us, so far,   and we are heavy users as a business…

  • Oh I don’t agree with the statement at all. To me fan pages are better than ever. Just different. 

  • Fan pages are not going to die because of the timeline change. The only way they would even become less important is if the billion users switch over to something like Google plus and find Facebook irrelevant. We think it’s possible that the people assuming that Fan pages are dead might just be the ones who are afraid of making the change. It is a big change and with that you have to learn the new ways and be more knowledgeable about the content that your community wants to hear. The change of timeliness is definitely not bigger than the huge change we are seeing from traditional marketing to new media marketing.

  • @scottayers

    interesting topic, scott. 
    to me, marketing in the new world of social media was the “real” complete change to how we market, and a much bigger reason to “freak out” than the navigational changes on facebook. 
    i’ve spent quite a bit of time reviewing them, and there are some really great enhancements… the “freak out” is most likely happening only because of the default landing page going away (but still very viable via other means). 

    if we want to market in this new world of social media, we will need to “let go” of the thinking that these channels are “replacements” for more traditional forms of marketing – specifically that we are not in control of them (!) and understand that we can practice landing pages and conversion strategies to our hearts content on our own websites, blogs, e-commerce shops instead.
    that being said, i’m guessing there will many many creative workarounds by marketers to make this new navigation work for them… and when it changes again down the road… which it undoubtedly will… freak out part 2! : )

    would love to read your final article – can you post a link here when it’s posted?

  • Great input! Well I’m doing a live webinar around 1pm est on this topic. I don’t want to post a link here as that may come across as me promoting myself. But you can find it on the page of Fan Page Engine on Facebook.

  • There’s nothing to panic about. All it’s doing is forcing brands to be more interactive. Not a bad thing. The fact you can’t blatantly advertise on your cover photo is an opportunity, not a barrier.

  • @scottayres

    man oh freakin’ man! i saw the squadcast on your website. :)  Love the way you write.

    i’ll try to tune in to the webinar.  i’m also getting ready to do a timeline update tonight with a bunch of very small businesses – who barely got their arms around the old layout – which in retrospect is probably a very good thing! 

  • Thanks Peg!

  • Hey Scott love the proactive approach you guys took for us fanpage members. I’m learning more everyday by just tune in on the podcast. And I’m ready for the webinar, too. Will you guys be going over the extra tab options?

  • @ashleyhyde has very intelligent points she makes. Change is occurring so rapidly, and when people start making money on the “new way” of thinking, “Stop the World Now!” 

    I also like  @pegsousa‘s post, because that encapsulates the force of change that is inevitable! It will become more costly to keep up (time, research and development) so there probably will be less profit until we catch up to the curve; but there should be higher end profits as fewer and fewer will be around at that point … IMHO.

  • yeah I honestly feel like this latest change to pages will weed out alot of the pretenders when it comes to pages. 

  • @scottayres @annfurnivall

    The timeline will be great for pages.  It brings on a wave of changes that will definitely benefit, not hurt, a business.   I dont see where all this fear and anxiety stems from. 

    On the otherhand, I hate timeline for profile pages.  Besides the cover photo, I have plenty of gripes with it.  But to be fair, I usually scorn change at first and then grow accustom to it.

    Tweet @GoOmnibeat

  • @scottayres I have found the changes with Timeline overall to be helpful for the pages I manage regularly. There is a lot of change but a colleague shared this article with me that helps others who haven’t yet switched to timeline. I thought you might want to check it out:  http://socialmediatoday.com/george-guildford/460521/facebook-timeline-brands-10-things-get-right

  • today showed me   nothing  had  changed much with my  fans.which  was a relief….  since it looks  pretty different  to me……. this morning  i put on  one  product photo,  big metal palm trees,  got  15 likes or  comments within    5  hrs….thats   pretty  good  for us….  …. 

    i dont like the  double  columns  but  guess i  better  get used to it….

  • @annfurnivall I am glad to hear your success story. It lends credibility to establishing a realistic budget to promote SMM.  @alexandrabriggs, that’s a great article! I do think George’s comment about losing the landing page emphasizes that most of the problem comes from the “Stop the World Now” syndrome I alluded to.

    Change is here, and will continue to evolve. It will take intuition, capital and creativity to compete. Capital can mean money or a network adding value to what you do. That’s why I like this forum; it is a part of my capital.

  • how about this?…..  the welcome page wont  take the place of the old landing  page,  rather it will shrink in  value and the visual  presentation of  the  whole page will be the important  thing, the new    landing page if  you like,,….

    thats  how im  going to manage mine  for now…

  • Hi
    Fan pages dead? In my opinion they are more alive than ever
    I think fan pages are getting better and better with Timeline new features. Facebook don’t make changes to ruin their business. They know very well what they are doing and in my opinion as a user they are doing it really well.
    Forget about your welcome page and focus in what really matters. With the Timeline you have more options than ever to make your business shine. 

  • @scottayres  Your right in some ways at first impressions when you switch from the old to new timeline it can be a little daunting and you are left to ask yourself what do I do with this now, where do I place that piece of information, and with the removal of the fangate some may think their fan page is dead…. Well, as app developers we have found that Facebook has really given more real-estate to work with, it has given greater opportunities to place more information on your page , and the ability to highlight your brand is just the beginning.
    We have been asked to develop some great apps that will turn your page into a powerhouse that will bring your brand information to one place without leaving Facebook and as business owners that’s what we want, and that’s what our clients want for their fanbase, so keep an eye out for that because it will be something to look forward to, and as quoted by @fernandocortes the on the timeline you will have more options than ever to make your business shine.
    Regards Alf

  • Yeah for me I think the switch to Timeline is great for profiles and pages. It’s way more real estate than we’ve ever had before. What this does though is force pages to be more social and less market-y. So the spammy internet marketers will hate the change.. But that’s ok with me.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Avatar ImageChris
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Avatar ImageLydia
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageJameson
KMediaIrelandKMediaIrel
Avatar ImageHarry
Avatar ImageAlexandra
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Rachel Agheyisi
Ann at  greenoak
Leah Rosin
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Kristy Henry