Content Creation vs. Content Curation (6 posts)

Topic tags: content marketing
  • Content creation vs. content curation has become a controversial subject at where I work. I hope my estimable colleagues can help out here. 

    Recently, we had a problem with content writers plagiarized content. After, running it through copyscape the aforementioned article where detected. Currently, we have set the bar at 85% content be authenticate.

    However, with content curation citing sources is a given however, how much content taken from an original article and pasted into a post even in blockquotes is allowed? 
    Does, anyone have a good contributor author guideline they want to share?

  • @ptwylie I only take original content from my guest authors – if I search for it and find it has been published elsewhere, I reject it. 

    As far as content curation, I would take a piece like “Top 20 Posts on ___” where they linked to another post and summarized it with a couple of sentences as to why it’s a great article.  If it’s just a paragraph from one article and a link, however, it’s really not that great content.  

    I only say that because I subscribe to a few blogs that mix in a great, original article with an article that just pulls a paragraph from someone else and link.  I’m always frustrated when I hit the latter.

  • @kristi-hines thank you Kristi for your insight! I tend to agree with you nothing frustrates me more than to see a a couple of copied paragraphs and a link back to an original article. Looks like some machine driven crap.

    I think taking someones point of view and adding value to it whether it is a different slant or build value by adding to it thus broadening the perspective is quite another thing and is quite acceptable. I do like the idea of “The Top 20 Posts of xxxxxxx. :)  

  • @kristi-hines thank you Kristi for your insight! I tend to agree with you nothing frustrates me more than to see a a couple of copied paragraphs and a link back to an original article. Looks like some machine driven crap.

    I think taking someones point of view and adding value to it whether it is a different slant or build value by adding to it thus broadening the perspective is quite another thing and is quite acceptable. I do like the idea of “The Top 20 Posts of xxxxxxx. :)  

  • @ptwylie  Occasionally, it’s definitely not a bad thing, especially if you are extending the original article’s point of view or adding to the ideas in it.  There’s one blog that I came across that came up with even craftier titles than the original, but then every article was just a quoted paragraph and link elsewhere.  Sadly, it was a business.

  • I’m in favour of original content. However taking quotes or arguing against a post is certainly acceptable.

    If your post is a direct copy of another post, you will actually damage both your own website and their website in the search rankings – Google will penalise duplicate content. Therefore you should avoid using any more than quotes in your articles.

    I think your 85% original content rule should be fine.Sam

  • United States copyright law says, “Under the fair use doctrine of the U.S. copyright statute, it is permissible to use limited portions of a work including quotes, for purposes such as commentary, criticism, news reporting, and scholarly reports. There are no legal rules permitting the use of a specific number of words, a certain number of musical notes, or percentage of a work. Whether a particular use qualifies as fair use depends on all the circumstances.”
    God only knows what Google says.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .

 
 
Check out the Social Media Marketing Podcast!

Networking Clubs Leaderboard

Avatar ImageE
Kristy C. CartierKristy
Ann at  greenoakAnn
Avatar ImageJudith
Avatar ImageAndré
Avatar ImageRobin
Avatar ImageScott
Avatar ImageJoleen
Kapil MudholkarKapil
Taryn MurrayTaryn
Learn more about the Networking Clubs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of
Zadok Tarei
Giacomo
Jason Chu
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Jose Jimenez
Thomas Völcker
Profile picture of
Suchi Goyal
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of
Profile picture of