Am I a spammer? (4 posts)

  • The company I work for has a blog, and we manage a professional group on LinkedIn as well. Every week we post in our blog a weekly review, a collection of the most interesting articles we have found during the week.  We promote the blog post in our LinkedIn group, with the link of our blog.  It gives pretty good linkbacks to our website. But I have just red that this system is  mistake, it’s like a self promotion, and will label us spammer. Is that true, or I didn’t get it right?

  • Hi @rekaesther  

    I don’t do a lot at LinkedIn so don’t have advice about LI per se, but what you have been doing does not sound ‘out of the way’ to me so much as to label your contributions as spamming.  If you are interacting in other ways with members and have made friends there, I’d say you are OK to self promote to a certain extent. See, social media is about relationships and interactions but with a little biz thrown into the mix every now and then. Nothing wrong with this approach.

    There is a line that many places do not want crossed and it seems that the line gets moved from time to time too.  Are the other members complaining to you? If they are, then perhaps you’ve stepped over, just a tad.

    .02

    Eileen ;)

  • Reka, the fact that you’re asking the question is a sign to me that you aren’t spamming…

    The problem is that every site has its own definition of spamming, its own rules of etiquette. It’s quite exhausting task to figure out just what that etiquette is, what the limits are, what they really want, and what they don’t want… as the rules seem to be different for differing sites.

    I can’t tell you about LinkedIn… mainly because there are two rules of thought there. Actually, three.

    One is written by LinkedIn, but very little help. The second is the group of folks there who are employees… networking for their companies and themselves in the natural course of business, promotional and better job opportunities. The third are a special breed of entrepreneurs or internet marketers who all they do is sell, sell, sell and don’t understand the “developing relationships” part of networking.

    I guess there is a fourth… probably where you and I fit in… where we want to do the right thing, but something doesn’t feel quite right no matter what we do there or which group of thinking we try to emulate. I think that’s called a working conscience, lol. I’d estimate most people there fit into that group.

    Robin Carlisle
    @rekaesther

  • @rekaesther If it’s your group, then you shouldn’t be considered a spammer. When it comes to groups owned by others, it could vary. Some groups say specifically in their rules that you can’t promote your own content, but for the most part, I’ve never seen complaints from the rest when someone promotes their own stuff so long as it is relevant to the main group topic and actually valuable. I’m not sure I would count them as great backlinks for SEO purposes though because I think LinkedIn uses a redirect. So the links are great for traffic, not necessarily great for rankings.


Add your voice to the discussion

Existing members: . If you do not have a SME account, .